A projeção do self do magistrado na decisão judicial e o controle de racionalidade a partir dos deveres de fundamentação
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This final paper seeks to address the issue of justification of judicial decisions,
with special attention to the grounding duties expressed by the Civil Procedure Code
of 2015, which aims at trying to prevent certain practices perpetrated by the Brazilian
legal community. Whilst establishing what will not be considered a justified decision,
this new law attempts to condense the interpreters’ activity as a form of rational
control on verdicts.
The first part of the study situates historically the role of the interpreter, talking
briefly about the models of interpretation that were developed over time, sometimes
reducing the role of the interpreter, sometimes expanding it. Then, it is analyzed the
formation and performance of the Brazilian jurist, indicating the profile of judges and
how judgments are made in the forensic practice.
The research is at its core, however, in the second part, which takes care of
analyzing the magistrate as an individual. Anchored in Charles Taylor's theory on selfsources,
it intends to verify how the elements that make up the background of the
individual works as a guiding sense of what is important or valuable, from which
emerges their insights on how to act, feel and react at different times.
It elaborates on the difficulty of separating the interprets’ interiority of his daily
activity as judge, demonstrating that the only way to avoid a deep legal relativism,
where the decision is merged with a personal choice of the judge, is through
argumentative reasoning, as long as clearly assumed the magistrates’
methodological options.
It is also analyzed the impacts of the expansion of interpreter's activity in
Brazilian society, especially with regards to judicial activism, in an increasingly closer
relationship between Law and Politics.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
