Impasses do segundo dualismo pulsional freudiano
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora
DOI
Abstract
With the impossibility of sustaining the first dualism, Freud was faced with the threat of
having to admit a drive monism. However, Freud always considered fundamental to assume a
dualism. In Beyond the Pleasure Principle (1920), when reflecting on the relationship
between the repetition compulsion and drive activity, he gets the concept of the death drive. In
opposition to this new drive class, Freud presents the life drive and, thus, replaces the first
drive dualism. Both drive classes would act with the emergence of life from inorganic matter.
While the death drive would return to the inorganic state, the life drive would make the life
more complex, making the death of the organism harder. However, the second dualism
hypothesis presents a number of difficulties which begs the question if Freud was able to
sustain this. In his work of 1920, he recognizes that the new drive dualism does not present
the same degree of certainty that the previous steps of the development of his theory of drives.
The objective here is, first, to analyze the theory presented in Beyond the Pleasure Principle
and discuss some of the main problems present in Freud's argument. Then we analyzed the
hypotheses developed by Freud regarding the two drive classes in later works in order to
analyze how he can sustain the primarity and independence of the two drive classes in the
remaining of his theory. We conclude that the impasses in the text of 1920 are not fully solved
and we try to point out the main issues that remain open in the Freudian theory about the
second drive dualism.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
