A utilização inconsistente do distinguishing como forma de afastamento da Súmula 593 do STJ: uma análise dos fundamentos adotados pelo Tribunal de Justiça de Minas Gerais nos casos envolvendo estupro de vulnerável
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
This study aims to analyze the use of the distinguishing technique by the Court of Justice of
Minas Gerais to set aside Precedent No. 593 of the Superior Court of Justice, in order to
assess whether the grounds adopted are compatible with the precedent’s ratio decidendi. First,
the theoretical foundations of judicial precedents are presented, with emphasis on stare
decisis, the identification of the ratio decidendi, and the functioning of the system of
precedents in the Brazilian legal order. Next, the techniques of distinguishing and overruling,
the requirements for the proper application of distinctions, and the risks arising from their
inconsistent use are examined. Subsequently, the development of Precedent No. 593 of the
Superior Court of Justice from Repetitive Theme No. 918 is analyzed, as well as its
application by the Court of Justice of Minas Gerais, with a focus on the grounds used to
justify its non-application, such as the formation of a family unit, parental approval, the
existence of an affective relationship, and the age difference between the defendant and the
victim. Finally, the Indianópolis case is examined as an example of inconsistent
distinguishing, demonstrating that the particular circumstances emphasized in the judgment
were not legally relevant enough to displace the determining reasons of the precedent. The
methodology was based on qualitative research conducted through a literature review,
documentary research, and a case-law survey of the official database of the Court of Justice of
Minas Gerais. Due to the confidentiality of the proceedings, the Indianópolis case was
reconstructed from news reports and publications available concerning the judgment.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

