Sentidos de docência em história em disputa: uma análise de concursos públicos para professores da educação básica
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Public teacher recruitment examinations are important tools within educational systems
because, by selecting teachers for public schools, they can strengthen teacher
professionalization by promoting teacher insertion and teacher professional development. In
this study, these examinations are understood as forms of assessment, and from a
post-foundational perspective (Burity, 2008; Mendonça & Rodrigues, 2014), this means that
their design produces discourses that interpellate meanings of teaching. The calls for
applications and examinations delimit the knowledge considered valid and necessary for
professional practice, configuring meanings of teaching through the valorization of particular
forms of teacher knowledge (Tardif, 2000; Shulman, 1986; Monteiro, 2007), experience,
training, etc. The aim of this research was to investigate the meanings of teaching produced,
contested, and hegemonized through public recruitment examinations for History teachers,
understanding that these meanings are not natural but rather the result of discursive disputes
that, in spaces such as these examinations, undergo provisional stabilizations regarding how
History teachers should be and what they should know. The analysis was based on the most
recent calls for applications and examinations conducted by the Brazilian states and the
Federal District, as well as on a more in-depth examination of 14 of these 27 exams, focusing
on aspects such as the assessment instruments adopted, the distribution of scores among them,
the most common question formats, and the most recurrent themes. The main finding of this
research was that these meanings of teaching have been remarkably similar across the
examinations analyzed, despite the diversity of examining boards and the absence of
legislation regulating these selection processes in greater detail. Drawing on the contributions
of Chantal Mouffe (2015), we understand that these shared presences and absences have
shaped—and are shaped by—an evaluative politics. Some characteristics of this assessment
policy include the unavoidable use of multiple-choice examinations, which concentrate the
highest scores and possess the greatest exclusionary power; greater prioritization of academic
background over professional experience; the near absence of practical examinations; and the
predominance of knowledge derived from the disciplinary knowledge in multiple-choice
assessments.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

