Plano Nacional de Saúde nos planos estaduais (2020–2023): análise da difusão da equidade nas 27 Unidades Federativas do Brasil
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Introduction: Equity is one of the guiding principles of the Brazilian Unified
Health System (SUS) and is incorporated into the guidelines of the National Health
Plan (PNS) 2020–2023. However, as a polysemic concept, its incorporation into
planning instruments may occur in different ways across state contexts. In this
scenario, it is important to understand how equity has been interpreted and
incorporated into the State Health Plans (PES) of Brazil’s 27 Federative Units.
Objective: To critically analyze the presence and definition of the concept of equity in
the National Health Plan (2020–2023) and its interpretation in the State Health Plans
of Brazil’s 27 Federative Units during the same period. Methods: This qualitative
documentary study was based on the policy diffusion through translation approach
and on categorical content analysis. The corpus consisted of the National Health
Plan (2020–2023) and the 27 State Health Plans in force during the same period.
The analysis examined the presence of the term equity, its frequency of occurrence,
contexts of use, explicit definitions, related terms, and forms of incorporation into the
documents. Data were organized using Microsoft Excel® spreadsheets and analyzed
in light of the theoretical framework of policy translation. Results: The term equity was
identified in 25 of the 27 State Health Plans analyzed, with considerable variation in
frequency across states. Only Mato Grosso and Tocantins did not mention the term.
The highest numbers of occurrences were observed in the plans of Rio Grande do
Norte (34 citations), Amazonas (31), and Minas Gerais (28). Only ten states provided
an explicit definition of equity: Amazonas, Federal District, Espírito Santo, Goiás,
Minas Gerais, Paraná, Piauí, Rio de Janeiro, Rio Grande do Sul, and Santa Catarina.
The identified definitions were grouped into four categories: equity as distributive
justice and differential treatment; equity based on the social determinants of health;
equity as the reduction of regional inequalities; and equity as a guideline for access
to and organization of the health system. Related terms were also analyzed,
particularly inequality, inequity, equality, and social justice, which were frequently
employed in situational analyses and institutional guidelines. Discussion: The findings
showed that, although equity is widely present in SUS planning instruments, its
definition and operationalization vary considerably among states. The diversity of
approaches identified reinforces the polysemic nature of the concept and suggests
that its incorporation occurs through processes of interpretation, adaptation, and re-
signification within state contexts. The differences observed reflect characteristics of
the translation processes through which national guidelines are incorporated at
subnational levels. Conclusion: Equity is widely present in health planning
instruments; however, its incorporation occurs heterogeneously across Brazilian
states. The presence of the term is not always accompanied by explicit definitions or
consistent operational strategies, highlighting the need to strengthen its conceptual
qualification within SUS planning instruments. The findings suggest that the diffusion
of equity does not occur through the mere reproduction of national guidelines but
rather through translation processes influenced by the territorial, institutional, and
political specificities of state contexts.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

