Jet lag social, cronotipos e direito à saúde: uma análise à luz da teoria dos direitos fundamentais
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Chronobiology shows that the persistent misalignment between the biological clock,
the chronotype, and social schedules is associated with social jet lag — a phenomenon linked
to harms to health and psychosocial well-being. In Brazilian law, this determinant dimension
of health is almost invisible, which justifies a legal-constitutional analysis. This work aimed
to investigate whether, and to what extent, the systematic mismatch between the biological
clock and the social organization of time, can be understood as a legally relevant restriction on
the fundamental right to health, especially for individuals with late chronotypes, in light of
Alexy’s Theory of Fundamental Rights (2024). Methodologically, the study combined
theoretical-dogmatic analysis and empirical investigation. In the first part, the content of the
right to health was reconstructed based on the fundamental rights theory, highlighting the
broad factual substrate, the state’s duties of protection and organization, and the
proportionality maxim as a standard for assessing restrictions. Next, the interdisciplinary
literature on chronotypes and social jet lag was systematized. In the empirical stage, a
self-administered online survey was conducted with a non-probabilistic convenience sample
of 303 respondents. The instrument, titled “Chronotype Questionnaire,” was based on the
Munich ChronoType Questionnaire (MCTQ) and gathered sociodemographic data, sleep
habits, self-assessed chronotype, and questions on psychological well-being, everyday
functioning, and experiences of stigmatization. The data was analyzed using descriptive
statistics and linear trend lines. The results indicated moderate to strong associations between
eveningness, higher social jet lag, and shorter average sleep duration. On average, all
chronotypes slept less than eight hours, suggesting a generalized scenario of suboptimal sleep
duration, with a heavier burden on later chronotypes. Although no robust linear associations
were observed between chronotype and severe depressive or anxious symptoms, late
chronotypes reported more difficulties in routine activities, a higher frequency of tardiness
due to oversleeping, and a greater likelihood of cancelling physical exercise because of
tiredness. The survey also revealed a strong association between late chronotypes and
comments that link habits or performance to “laziness,” “carelessness,” or “disorganization”.
Earlier chronotypes were more often associated with “diligence,” “care,” or “discipline”,
which suggests that chronotype operates as a social marker of perceived competence and
supports the hypothesis of stigmatization of evening profiles. In light of the theoretical
framework adopted, the study concluded that disregarding social jet lag and the diversity of
chronotypes in human populations can be characterized as a relevant restriction on the
fundamental right to health, whose burdens fall disproportionately on individuals with late
chronotypes. This entails a state duty to consider chronobiological diversity in the formulation
of public policies and in the organization of social schedules, especially with respect to
competitive civil service examinations and college entrance exams, school start times, and
working hours, including incentives for chronoworking arrangements, policies which, if
adopted, would constitute true social innovations. In this sense, to secure the optimized
protection of the right to health, such measures, if unfeasible, require rational justification by
the State, grounded in the proportionality maxim.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Embargado

