Team-Based Learning versus metodologia tradicional: avaliação do ensino-aprendizagem dos preceitos éticos e normativos no curso de Odontologia
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
The practice of Dentistry requires a solid ethical and regulatory foundation;
notably, ignorance of these norms does not exempt practitioners from professional
liability. Amidst a context of rising complaints and intense market competitiveness,
the teaching and learning of these concepts during undergraduate studies play a
pivotal role in preparing students for professional conduct that is both ethical and
compliant with occupational standards. Thus, the objective of this study was to
quantitatively evaluate whether the application of the active Team-Based Learning
(TBL) methodology improved student learning regarding the profession's ethical and
regulatory precepts compared to traditional methodology, as well as to qualitatively
assess student perceptions regarding both methods. To this end, a controlled trial
was conducted with 50 students enrolled in the Forensic Dentistry and Deontology
course at the Federal University of Juiz de Fora, Governador Valadares Campus.
Participants were divided into two in-person groups: Group T (traditional), comprising
17 students who completed an individual multiple-choice test on ethical and
regulatory content based on knowledge acquired through lecture-based classes; and
the TBL Group, comprising 33 students who were subjected to the TBL methodology
to learn the same content, involving the administration of the test individually followed
by a group phase. Student satisfaction was assessed in both groups post-activity
using a Likert-scale questionnaire by Google Forms®. Quantitatively, 49 responses
were obtained (Group T: 18; TBL Group: 31). The TBL Group demonstrated better
performance in the collaborative stage (mean score of 98.0%), which was superior to
the individual performance of both groups (Group T: 86.7%; TBL Group: 87.0%);
medical record custody and price advertising were identified as the topics of greatest
difficulty. Qualitatively, there was a clear preference for active methodologies, with
TBL showing high acceptance, and 100% of students agreed that the activities
contributed to and promoted a greater understanding of the content. Although both
groups agreed that lecture-based classes effectively transmit content (over 94%),
there was a distinction regarding attention and motivation: the TBL Group (83.9%
versus 61.1% in Group T) demonstrated greater ease in maintaining attention and
higher motivation during theoretical classes. Satisfaction with post-activity feedback
was maximal in the TBL Group (100%) and high in Group T (89%), highlighting the
importance of this stage. Specifically within the TBL Group, methodology acceptance was high: 100% of participants agreed that the preparatory material (booklet and
manual) combined with individual and group activities aided in learning the subject,
and 90.3% reported a greater understanding of the content following the TBL
session. This high acceptance extended to the expansion of the methodology, with
80.6% of TBL participants expressing a desire for other disciplines to adopt similar
active approaches. In Group T, although the majority considered multiple-choice
evaluations effective, 50% disagreed with preferring them over dynamic interactive
activities and assessment with group discussion, indicating a valuation of the social
and interactive dimensions in the learning process. It is concluded that, despite the
performance gain between the individual and group phases in the TBL Group, test
averages did not show significant divergence, as scores were high in both groups.
However, the students' appreciation and preference for the TBL methodology indicate
that it is an effective strategy to assist in the teaching and learning of the ethical and
regulatory content of the course.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

