Avaliação de impacto algorítmico (AIA): ferramenta para accountability, uso e desenvolvimento ético de IA pelo poder judiciário
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This paper investigates the development of governance and algorithmic accountability
mechanisms for artificial intelligence (AI) systems in the Brazilian Judiciary, proposing an
Algorithmic Impact Assessment (AIA) methodology for the use of AI development in the
judicial context. The study is based on the observation of the growing use and development of
AI systems in the Judiciary and the recently approved Resolution 615 of the National Council
of Justice (CNJ), which represents a paradigmatic transformation in the administration of
justice. The research addresses the risks of algorithmic discrimination, decision-making
opacity, and violation of fundamental rights, especially regarding vulnerable groups. Using a
qualitative and interdisciplinary methodology, it combines normative and documentary analysis
with a comparative study of international regulatory frameworks. The theoretical framework
articulates two perspectives: critical theory of technology (Crawford, Zuboff, Eubanks) and
democratic accountability theory (Bovens), proposing a methodology for assessing algorithmic
impact (Mantelero). The research is structured around four axes: mapping AI systems in the
judiciary; analysis of ethical and legal risks; construction of accountability bases; and
development of an AIA methodology. It is argued that the current mechanisms established by
CNJ Resolution No. 615/2025, although representing progress, are insufficient to ensure
effective accountability. As a main contribution, an AIA methodology is proposed that
integrates technical, legal, and social safeguards, aiming to ensure transparency, prevent
discrimination, and protect fundamental rights, balancing technological innovation with the
constitutional values of the Brazilian justice system.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

