Provas em vídeo no processo judicial: o impacto do olho vivo nas decisões de primeiro grau em Minas Gerais
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Due to the constant evolution of technology and its increasing use by society in various
ways, this research aimed to investigate the impact of video evidence from the Olho Vivo
system on the basis of criminal sentences on the merits, whether or not they are guilty, handed
down in the first instance of jurisdiction. It is based on the theoretical framework of Jessica
Silbey, who problematizes the reflection on the interpretation of video, arguing that video would
be a constructed medium, presenting a certain point of view, including and also excluding
certain images, based precisely on the point of view of the person filming. In order to achieve
the main objective, keywords were adopted as criteria for the search of sentences, within a
delimited period, within the scope of the Court of Justice of the State of Minas Gerais (TJMG).
In addition to the general objective of verifying the impact of the Olho Vivo system on first
instance sentences, some of the specific objectives were defined as: to verify whether or not
judges, when issuing decisions, mention the video; whether the content of the video is known
through other evidentiary means and, if so, what type of evidence is given greater value. After
the research, it was found that there is a tendency to value the video indirectly, so that the video
content was generally known through another type of evidence, in most cases, through the
testimony of the military police officer who participated in the incident and attended the scene
of the incident. Since the criminal prosecution began as a result of the cameras of the Olho Vivo
system, it was found that this system has a considerable impact on the decision handed down.
In order to better explore the research, we sought to analyze the content of some specific
sentences and the judgments handed down in the respective appeals, in order to find out whether
the judges had the same stance as the first instance judges. Analyzing each sentence and
judgment researched, it was found that there is no uniformity in the decisions, with some in
which the filming is treated as important and others as dispensable. It was also confirmed that
direct assessment of video evidence still does not occur in most cases, probably due to the need
for visual literacy.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

