Efeitos da amplitude de movimento nos exercícios resistidos: respostas na hipertrofia e força muscular
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The manipulation of range of motion (ROM) directly influences the muscular
adaptations resulting from resistance training (RT). Despite this, the absence of
specific practical guidelines to optimize the development of maximal strength and
muscle hypertrophy, combined with inconsistencies in the literature, highlights the
need for a deeper understanding of this topic. Therefore, this thesis aimed to
analyze, through a systematic review and a controlled experiment, the effects of
RT performed with different ranges of motion on muscle hypertrophy and maximal
strength, considering participant characteristics and the training protocols
employed.
For Study 1, the systematic review, the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic
Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines were followed, with eligibility
criteria defined according to the PICOS framework: (P) healthy men and women
over 18 years old, (I) dynamic strength exercises performed with partial range of
motion (pROM), (C) dynamic strength exercises with full range of motion (fROM),
(O) maximal strength and muscle hypertrophy development, and (S) randomized
or non-randomized clinical trials with a minimum duration of six weeks. Searches
were conducted on June 16, 2024, in the EMBASE, MEDLINE (via PubMed®),
and Web of Science – Core Collection databases, and the methodological quality
of the studies was assessed using the Physiotherapy Evidence Database
(PEDro) scale.
Nineteen studies were included, totaling 627 participants (42.26% untrained,
30.62% trained, 4.14% physically active, 9.4% with little RT experience, and
13.55% with a mixed sample). The exercises covered included upper and lower
limbs, as well as single-joint and multi-joint movements. The average
methodological quality score was 5.9 (±1.2), indicating moderate quality, with only
one study classified as low quality. The main findings of the review showed that
for elbow flexor hypertrophy during the Scott curl, there was no clear advantage
of fROM over pROM, whereas for muscle strength, fROM tended to produce
better results. In the leg extension exercise, both ROM types led to similar
hypertrophy and strength gains, except when pROM was performed at longer
muscle lengths, which enhanced outcomes. Therefore, muscle length during
pROM may be a determining factor for superior gains.
However, when analyzing the results of the studies that investigated the squat
exercise, it was observed that the fROM group achieved greater hypertrophy of
the anterior thigh muscles, thigh adductors, and gluteus maximus. Similarly,
regarding muscle strength gains, the fROM group showed significantly greater
improvements than the pROM group.
For the bench press exercise, there is insufficient evidence to support
conclusions regarding strength gains with fROM due to the limited number of
studies and heterogeneous samples. Importantly, to date, no studies have
analyzed the effect of ROM on hypertrophy for this exercise.
Therefore, it can be concluded that ROM does not have a major influence on
hypertrophy and strength outcomes when training with the Scott curl and leg
extension exercises. However, for the squat, training with fROM may result in
greater hypertrophic and strength stimuli. For the bench press, the results remain
inconclusive.
Additionally, Study 2, a controlled experiment with ten physically active young
men (age = 22.90 ± 2.47 years; body mass = 83.85 ± 11.67 kg; height = 176.30
± 6.22 cm) directly compared final partial range of motion (final pROM) with full
range of motion (fROM). The randomized within-subject experimental design
involved resistance training for both upper and lower limbs, three times per week
for six weeks, with three sets of 12 repetitions at 60% of one-repetition maximum
(1-RM) and a two-minute rest interval between sets and limbs.
The results showed no statistically significant differences for elbow flexor
hypertrophy (p = 0.920; Cohen’s d = 0.046) and knee extensor hypertrophy (p =
0.291; Cohen’s d = 0.152), nor for arm 1-RM (p = 0.161; Cohen’s d = 0.898) and
thigh 1-RM (p = 0.276; Cohen’s d = 0.533). However, the moderate-to-large effect
sizes favoring final pROM for strength suggest a trend worth exploring in future
studies with physically active young men.
In summary, the combined results from the systematic review and the experiment
indicate that different ranges of motion may lead to similar adaptations in muscle
hypertrophy and strength, although longer muscle lengths and the use of final
pROM show potential for superior results in certain contexts. The findings
supported the evidence from the systematic review, confirming that ROM
manipulation has variable impacts depending on the exercise and the muscle
group involved. Together, these findings contribute to refining evidence-based
guidelines for resistance training prescription focused on strength and muscle
hypertrophy. Further research is recommended to confirm these findings and to
establish more specific practical guidelines for prescribing ranges of motion in
resistance training.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

