Assédio judicial: estudo de caso da litigância abusiva contra o jornalista João Paulo Cuenca
Carregando...
Data
Autores
Título da Revista
ISSN da Revista
Título de Volume
Editor
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Resumo
This study examines the phenomenon of judicial harassment, understood as the
abusive use of legal actions to intimidate and silence critical voices, through the case
of journalist João Paulo Cuenca. In 2020, after publishing a satirical statement referring
to a political figure and a religious organization, Cuenca became the target of 145
lawsuits for moral damages filed individually by members of the Universal Church of
the Kingdom of God across various Brazilian states. The general objective was to
analyze the legal and social implications of this emblematic case in order to understand
the patterns of judicial harassment in Brazil. Specifically, the study mapped the lawsuits
in terms of geographic distribution, plaintiffs’ profiles, legal grounds, requested
remedies, and judicial decisions, aiming to identify evidence of predatory litigation. A
qualitative methodology was adopted, including a literature review, analysis of
legislation and case law, and a case study based on document analysis of the legal
proceedings and related sources. The results indicate that the lawsuits against Cuenca
exhibit typical characteristics of judicial harassment: a multiplicity of similar claims,
dispersion across different jurisdictions, standardized pleadings, and high
compensation amounts (with totals reaching several million reais), along with
censorship measures such as court orders for public retraction and bans on further
expression by the defendant. It was found that this litigation strategy was used as a
tool to curtail the journalist’s freedom of expression, constituting an abuse of the right
to sue with an intimidating effect (chilling effect) on both the defendant and other
journalists. The study concludes that the Cuenca case exemplifies the risks that judicial
harassment poses to freedom of expression and highlights the need for more effective
legal mechanisms to curb such practices. Possible responses include the strict
enforcement of existing sanctions for bad-faith litigation in procedural law and the
adoption of specific anti-SLAPP legislation, already proposed in the National
Congress, in order to prevent the predatory use of the judicial system for purposes of
private censorship.
Descrição
Palavras-chave
Citação
Coleções
Avaliação
Revisão
Suplementado Por
Referenciado Por
Licença Creative Commons
Exceto quando indicado de outra forma, a licença deste item é descrita como Acesso Aberto

