Diálogos interinstitucionais nos cuidados à saúde da pessoa com deficiência: uma análise dos diálogos entre o Conselho Municipal de Saúde de Juiz de Fora (CMS/JF), o Poder Judiciário e o Ministério Público
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The present study analyzes interinstitutional dialogue practices between the Municipal
Health Council of Juiz de Fora (CMS/JF), the Public Prosecutor's Office, and the
Judiciary in the context of implementing the Care Network for Persons with Disabilities
(RCPD), established by Ordinance No. 793/2012. Considering the increase in healthrelated judicialization and the need for integration among various institutional actors
within the Unified Health System (SUS), the research aims to investigate the
interactions between these institutions in the oversight and implementation of public
policies focused on the health of persons with disabilities. The study adopts an
empirical approach based on qualitative methodology, using content analysis as the
primary investigative technique. Minutes and resolutions from the CMS/JF between
2012 and 2024 were examined to identify patterns, trends, and gaps in discussions
and decisions related to the health of persons with disabilities. An inductive-deductive
reasoning process was employed, starting with an inductive approach to uncover
emerging themes from the analyzed records, followed by a deductive analysis
grounded in Friedman's and Hiebert's theories on interinstitutional dialogue. The
results revealed that judicial decisions are frequent topics in CMS/JF debates, driving
both the search for public health solutions and the process of justifying executive
decisions and ensuring accountability. Key dialogue mechanisms were discussed,
such as the creation of the Municipal List of Essential Medicines (REMUME) and the
establishment of multidisciplinary committees to support judicial decisions. The Public
Prosecutor's Office was identified as a key actor in problem-solving and policy
implementation, whereas the lack of active participation from the Judiciary was
highlighted as a barrier to effective interinstitutional dialogue. Additionally, the CMS/JF
faces organizational limitations, particularly regarding the predominance of Health
Department representatives, documentation issues, and meeting records. Although
issues related to the health of persons with disabilities are prioritized in national
policies, they were often addressed superficially in local discussions. The study
concludes that the CMS/JF plays a central role as a coordinating body in planning and
implementing public policies for persons with disabilities. However, it faces significant
challenges, especially in effectively implementing dialogue mechanisms with the
Judiciary and the Public Prosecutor's Office, as well as in fully realizing national
guidelines. Overcoming these barriers requires strengthening documentation
practices, institutionalizing dialogue with the Judiciary, and promoting greater
adherence to inclusive health policies.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

