Inteligência artificial e poder judiciário: estudo comparativo entre Brasil, União Europeia (UE) e EUA
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This research discusses the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools in the Judiciary, especially
the AI in use in the Federal Supreme Court (STF) and the Superior Court of Justice (STJ). The
theoretical framework adopted was the work of authors Cláudia Toledo, Fabiano Hartmann
Peixoto and Robert Alexy. The main objective was to critically analyze the use of AI tools by
the Brazilian Judiciary, its benefits and risks in order to contribute to the advancement of
knowledge regarding the application and control of AI. The specific objectives were to define
AI; to outline the general panorama of AI in the Brazilian Judiciary and analyze the Victor
programs in the STF and Athos in the STJ; to qualitatively analyze the regulatory initiatives for
general AI in Brazil, the EU and the USA. Methodologically, bibliographic research was carried
out, using the deductive method and an analytical-interpretive approach of national and foreign
doctrinal works; (ii) documentary research, using as sources the official websites of the Federal
Senate, the National Council of Justice (CNJ) and the STF and STJ primarily; for the European
context, research was carried out on the website of the European Commission and for the US
context on the official website of the US Congress and the White House. For documentary
analysis, the research was carried out on the research reports published by the Getúlio Vargas
Foundation's Center for Innovation, Administration and Research in the Judiciary
(CIAPJ/FGV) in 2020, 2022 and 2023. The time frame of the research was January 2019 to
March 2024. The activities carried out by AI systems in the main Brazilian Superior Courts
were analyzed: i) the STF, as it is the country's Supreme Court; ii) the STJ, as it is related to
ordinary justice and receives a significant volume of cases from lower courts. The main results
found in this study were that the AI tools in use in the higher courts delimited are still under
development and that there is still no consistent public data on the real impact of these tools on
judicial decision-making. The evidence showed that (i) the risk of cognitive biases and
algorithms is still high; (ii) there is a lack of transparency in the description of data on how AI
works on the official websites of the courts and the CNJ; (iii) there is no transparency for the
user as to the degree of interference of this tool in decision-making activity; (iv) there is an
incompatibility between the way a judicial decision is produced by a human and the way an AIgenerated decision is produced; (v) there are still many gaps in the governance instruments of
these tools, especially in relation to the human review of decisions and the auditability of
systems.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

