Teoria da mente em adultos: um estudo exploratório da compreensão de enunciados irônicos em adultos privados de liberdade
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Theory of Mind (ToM) is a cognitive capacity related to the representation and attribution of
one’s own and others’ mental states. It may be understood either as a specialized module for
processing specific types of information (FODOR, 1983b) or as a mechanism emerging from
social cognition, on which other mental functions depend (TOMASELLO, 2003). This
capacity begins to develop in early childhood, and studies suggest that its functioning may be
influenced by subjective experiences throughout adulthood (APPERLY et al., 2011;
MARTINS; BARRETO; CASTIAJO, 2014; TOLEDO; RODRIGUES, 2017). Within this
framework, different socialization conditions may affect how individuals interpret intentions,
attitudes, and implicit meanings in communicative situations. This study investigates the
relationship between ToM and the comprehension of nonliteral utterances — especially irony
— in incarcerated adults. The central hypothesis posits that the prison environment, as a
specific social context, may impact interpretive abilities that rely on mental state attribution.
To explore this, an experimental study was conducted using linguistic tasks involving ironic
praise and ironic criticism (DEWS; WINNER, 1995; NONATO, 2020). Data were collected
through three instruments: (i) a sociodemographic questionnaire; (ii) the Multidimensional
Sense of Humor Scale (MSHS), translated into European Portuguese (JOSÉ; PARREIRA,
2008) and adapted for this study; and (iii) the Strange Stories protocol (HAPPÉ, 1994;
O'HARE et al., 2009), also adapted for the target population. The sample included 11 adults
serving sentences in closed-regime incarceration and 40 non-incarcerated participants,
grouped by educational level. Responses for instrument (iii) were classified as “target” or
“non-target” according to previously established interpretive accuracy criteria. Results
revealed statistically significant differences between groups, with higher performance among
non-incarcerated participants. A greater number of target responses were observed for critical
utterances (both literal and ironic) compared to praise, with ironic praise yielding the lowest
number of target responses across all groups. These findings support the hypothesis that social
and contextual factors influence ToM functioning in adulthood and suggest possible effects of
incarceration on the comprehension of nonliteral linguistic content. Moreover, the results are
consistent with previous studies employing online methods (NONATO, 2020).
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

