Standards probatórios para a admissibilidade da prova digital no direito processual civil brasileiro
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The present work views evidence as the construction of knowledge within the scope of judicial
proceedings. To this end, it is argued that such knowledge, under the lens of epistemology,
seeks to demonstrate the correspondence between factual statements and truth, the latter being,
in its purest form, absolute. However, the absoluteness of truth should not be conflated with the
probabilistic and relative nature of this knowledge, that is, evidence. Furthermore, the
hypothesis guiding this research reflects a shift in how we communicate and record life events,
which, in turn, has impacted how knowledge is generated and obtained/extracted. In this
context, digital evidence emerges, originating in a virtual (immaterial) environment or being
transported into it. Given the volatile nature of digital evidence, which can be imperceptibly
manipulated to the naked eye, the following methodological problem arises how to ensure a
minimum level of reliability of such evidence when admitted into judicial proceedings. Thus,
the general objective of this study is to analyze procedural institutes and instruments capable of
ensuring, in probabilistic terms, a minimum level of reliability for digital evidence to be
admitted into judicial proceedings. Accordingly, evidentiary standards were identified as a
potential solution to the presented problem, as they harmonize the highly dynamic nature of
technology, the intrinsically probabilistic character of evidentiary reasoning, and the
indispensable definition of a threshold in the admissibility framework, allowing this immaterial
element to be considered minimally reliable. Additionally, it was found that the current criteria
for the admissibility of evidence in Civil Procedural Law are insufficient to address the
technological and highly mutable nature of digital evidence. Through evidentiary standards, it
is argued that when admitting an immaterial element into proceedings, the methodology used
in its collection should be demonstrated, and these methods should be testable or falsifiable
through existing and technologically valid knowledge. This research identified the somewhat
overlooked Incidente de Assunção de Competência (Incident of Assumption of Competence)
as a viable mechanism for establishing these standards, as it is a procedural tool designed to
standardize the interpretation of relevant legal issues with significant social impact. This
instrument allows higher courts to decide specific issues, creating binding precedents to guide
future decisions. Concerning the admissibility of digital evidence, the Incidente de Assunção
de Competência is seen as a mechanism with virtues for establishing clear parameters for the
collection, preservation, and analysis of these immaterial elements. This ensures that the
methods used are technically demonstrable and verifiable, promoting a more secure procedural
system aligned with technological innovations.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

