A inconstitucionalidade da prisão temporária no Brasil: análise crítica das ações diretas de inconstitucionalidade de n. 3360/DF e 4109/DF
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
Prison, especially precautionary, in a constitutional paradigm must be identified as
one of the final and exceptional consequences of a redemocratized Criminal
Procedural Law and will only be valid if it follows constitutional dictates. The
panorama after 1988 imposes guarantor hermeneutics and the defense of freedom
as the rule in the country. Therefore, each and every prison must go through a
rigorous review in which the limitations to its application, given its harmfulness to the
dignity of the human person, must be a central point. More than that, in some cases,
certain prisons, released or inspired by the period of the Military Dictatorship, must be
problematized by the need to take the paradigm of the Democratic Rule of Law
seriously. In this sense, the central theme of this research is to analyze temporary
imprisonment, in its history, application and validity, especially after the Federal
Supreme Court, due to the direct actions of unconstitutionality of n. 3360/DF and no.
4.109/DF consider it constitutional. The research seeks to problematize this decision,
which, although it has brought strict requirements for the application of the indicated
precautionary arrest, does not consider that this, according to the hypothesis that will
be defended, is unconstitutional in its formal and material scope and, according to the
primacies of criminal guarantees, is incompatible with the paradigm adopted by the
Brazilian legal system. In this sense, the problem theme reflects the need to identify
that the Supreme Court's decision defending the constitutionality of temporary
imprisonment must be rethought. The justification for the research is faced with the
need to establish a hermeneutical basis whose orientation is historicized and
constitutionalized. Therefore, based on a qualitative methodology, based on a
bibliographic review about the institute, with an emphasis on the guarantor approach
(which constitutes our theoretical framework), we seek to analyze the application of
criminal procedural provisions and provisions relating to temporary imprisonment in
our constitutional order.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

