A lei de acesso à informação como instrumento de fiscalização do interesse público em contratos de transferência de tecnologia: um estudo de caso da vacina para a dengue
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
Dengue, the most common urban arboviral disease in the Americas, particularly in
Brazil, has emerged as a febrile illness of significant public health relevance over the past few
years. The increasing number of cases and sanitary needs have led Brazil to explore alternatives
for the prevention, control, and treatment of this disease. In 2010, the Butantan Institute made
efforts to develop what would be the first dengue vaccine in the world, in cooperation with the
United States National Institutes of Health. The study phases took place in both Brazil and the
United States, with the participation of the pharmaceutical company Merck, Sharp & Dohme.
Currently, according to information presented by the Institute, the development of the vaccine
is nearing completion. However, there is still limited information available about these
relationships. In this context, the public disclosure of this data is relevant, as it serves as a tool
to verify the observance of public and social interest in the legal relationship formed—a fact
that is significant not only due to the public health needs in Brazil but also because of the
effective participation of public law institutes in the production of the vaccine. It should also be
noted that the right to information is a constitutionally guaranteed right and is regulated by its
own instrument, such as the Access to Information Law (LAI). In this context, the present work
sought to verify, based on the instruments guaranteed by the LAI, whether there are indications
that the relationship between the Butantan Institute and the pharmaceutical company Merck
Sharp and Dohme is being guided by public health needs. To pursue this goal, the chosen
methodology was the exploratory Case Study, following the teachings of Robert Yin (2015).
The theoretical framework is based on the distinction presented by Zenon Bankowski (2008)
regarding the morality of aspiration and the morality of duty in legal norms. In general, it was
observed that there is no compliance, on the part of the Butantan Institute and the state agencies
of São Paulo, with the norms related to the right to information. Consequently, it is not possible
to assess to what extent the current negotiations are considering the interests of the community.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

