O efeito backlash e as decisões do Supremo Tribunal Federal
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This paper examines the backlash effect in order to identify its occurrence as a reaction to the
countermajority decisions of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court (STF) on matters deemed to
polemic. This is justified by the importance of equilibrium in the relations between the Judicial
Branch, the political powers of the State and society. In order to identify the occurrence of the
backlash effect in reaction to those decisions, we (1) studied the origin of the backlash effect;
(2) analyzed its conceptual treatment in order to identify the definition to be adopted; (3)
examined the elements of the judicial decision - ratio decidendi, rationales, obiter dicta - in
order to extract its core or thesis, and contrast it with its effects, verifying whether or not the
phenomenon in question occurred. Bibliographic research was carried out in foreign and
domestic works, in addition to empirical research in different documental sources: (1) fourteen
judicial decisions of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court indicated by the doctrine as
generating a backlash effect; (2) two Brazilian newspapers with high circulation, in order to
verify the occurrence of a social backlash effect; (3) programs of the parties of the Presidents
of the Republic who appointed the Ministers of the Federal Supreme Court voting in those 15
decisions, in order to examine the possible association of the backlash effect with left or rightwing governments. We also conducted legislative research on laws and constitutional
amendments, doctrinally cited as contrary to the Federal Supreme Court's decisions, in order to
confirm the occurrence of a legislative backlash effect. From the analysis of the 15 decisions
selected, 13 cases of backlash effect were identified; 7 of these presented a social backlash
effect (ADI 3105-8, ADI 3510, ADPF 187, ADPF 186, ADPF 153, ADPF 132, and ADPF 54)
and 6 presented a legislative backlash effect (ADI 14, RE 153771-0, RE 233332-6, RE 197917-
8, ADI 4983, and ADPF 153).
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso aberto

