O limite da competência do juiz de garantias brasileiro: um diálogo entre o sistema acusatório e o Supremo Tribunal Federal após julgamento da ADI 6.298
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
This article focuses on analyzing the jurisdiction and operational limits of the “Juiz de
Garantias” in the Brazilian legal system, considering the introduction of the role by the 2019
“Pacote Anticrime” and subsequent rulings by the brazilian Supreme Federal Court,
particularly in ADI 6.298. The research adopts a qualitative methodology, with doctrinal,
legislative, and jurisprudential analysis, aiming to understand the impact of implementing the
Guarantee Judge on the Brazilian criminal procedure. The theoretical foundations that justify
the creation of this new legal figure and its compatibility with the accusatory system are
discussed, highlighting how the Guarantee Judge (“Juiz de Garantias”) aligns with the
principles of impartiality, efficiency, and protection of fundamental rights. It is then
demonstrated how these elements are addressed by the Federal Supreme Court in the “ADI “
(“Ação Declaratória de Inconstitucionalidade”) 6.298 ruling, focusing on the limitation of the
Guarantee Judge's jurisdiction. The results indicate that, although the Federal Supreme Court
rhetorically supports the guidelines of the accusatory system, its decision-making practice
shows a tendency to maintain the judge's participation in the evidence-gathering process.
Furthermore, under the dynamic proposed by the Guarantee Judge in the “Anti-Crime
Package” (“Pacote Anticrime”) the trial judge is still granted access to the investigative
dossier, under the pretext of the presumption of impartiality. Thus, the incompatibility
between the brazilian Supreme Court's decision in ADI 6.298 and the accusatory system in
criminal procedure is evident, within a context of fostering a "mixed" criminal procedure.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

