Um repensar sobre a confissão no processo penal brasileiro: pesquisa empírica em julgados do Tribunal de Justiça de Minas Gerais
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
Despite the epistemic distrust that should fall on confessions, this evidence is one of the most
persuasive in criminal procedural law. An admission of guilt is very convincing to anyone,
whether a layperson or even a magistrate. After all, why would an individual admit to
committing a crime they didn't commit? This common notion has led to an underestimation of
the occurrence of false confessions. However, scientific advances in police investigations have
led to evidence of several cases of miscarriages of justice in which crimes were falsely admitted.
These discoveries have prompted studies aimed at analyzing the factors that contribute to the
generation of false confessions and possible solutions to mitigate this phenomenon, the main
problems being identified in police interrogations. In Brazil, where there is no record of
miscarriages of justice due to false confessions, it is not possible to say that they do not exist.
The Brazilian legal system also has an aggravating factor: the sentencing judge is also
responsible for receiving the initial accusatory statement, something that will remain after the
recent interpretation of the investigation judge by the Brazilian Supreme Court. Therefore, even
if the confession is retractable, the judge will have analyzed the first confession, produced out
of court, under controversial conditions, psychologically contaminated by that admission of
authorship. Given this, this dissertation aimed to analyze the current treatment of confessions
in Brazil and to investigate proposals for improving the reliability of this piece of evidence. The
hypothesis formulated is that the confession exerts enormous persuasion on the conviction of
judges, and, for this reason, the Brazilian legal system lacks epistemic increments on the
subject, increments that can be proposed from the interdisciplinary approach between Law and
Psychology. The theoretical framework adopted consists of the adoption of contributions from
epistemology in procedural law, understanding the process as an instrument designed to obtain
knowledge about the truth of the facts, truth here understood as correspondence. Quantitative
and qualitative empirical research was then carried out on judgments published by the Tribunal
de Justiça de Minas Gerais, verifying almost 100% of convictions in cases in which there were
confessions and verifying the practical non-occurrence of acquittals in cases of judicial
retractions or the exercise of the right to silence in court. Pre-procedural confessions were
practically always valued, even though there were allegations that the admission of guilt was
involuntary. In conclusion, the hypothesis was confirmed, demonstrating that the confession is
still an extremely persuasive element for judges, regardless of when it was produced, and that
there are concrete proposals to make it more reliable, in favor of fairer judicial decisions.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

