Movimentos argumentativos em audiências preliminares no Juizado Especial Criminal
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The Special Criminal Court (JECrim) is an organ of the judiciary responsible for judging
criminal misdemeanors and crimes of lesser offensive potential whose penalties do not exceed
two years in prison. The preliminary hearing takes place before the complaint is filed and is
characterized by the attempt to archive the case and, consequently, reduce the overload of
processes at JECrim (MIRANDA, 2019; MACHADO 2023). Therefore, this speech-ininteraction event is eminently argumentative, and, depending on the conciliator's power of
persuasion, the archiving proposal will be successful or not. Considering the specificities of
this situational context, the objectives of this work are to map the argumentative movements
(cf. GILLE, 2001) presented by participants in three hearings at JECrim in a city in Minas
Gerais; investigate the role of argumentation in fulfilling the institutional mandate
(MAYNARD, 1984) and analyze the structure and content of supporting arguments. The data,
recorded in audio and transcribed according to the convention of conversation analysts
(SACKS, SCHEGLOFF and JEFFERSON, 1974), belong to the collection of the CNPq
Research Group “Language Practices in Legal Contexts”. The research is qualitative and
interpretative (DENZIN and LINCOLN, 2005) and is inserted in the subarea of Applied
Linguistics of Professions (SARANGI, 2005). To analyze the argumentation, we combined
the three components proposed by Schiffrin (1987) with the argumentative movements
predicted by Gille (2001). Furthermore, we resorted to the literature on types of argument
(PERELMAN EOLBRECHTS - TYTECA, 1958; GARCIA, 1978; BILLIG, 1987) and
narrative studies (LABOV, 1972; BAMBERG AND GEORGAKOPOULOU, 2008). We also
made use of the argumentation models developed by Vieira (2003, 2007). The results of the
study show, in the JECrim hearings, the use of argumentative movements already foreseen by
Gille (2001) and Vieira (2003, 2007), but they reveal the emergence of a specific MA in this
context, namely PECON. Furthermore, we found that the conciliator pursues the fulfillment
of its institutional goal, sometimes arguing in favor of archiving, sometimes defending the
non-opening of future processes. Depending on the participants' reaction, the argument is
brief or gradually constructed in several turns of speech, through the insertion of analogies,
arguments from authority, legal evidence, evidence, narratives, common sense, and syllogism.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

