Erro, inadequação, desvio ou problema: como os professores de português língua materna analisam textos de brasileiros e de estrangeiros
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This study investigates the correlation between the approaches of Portuguese native
language teachers regarding the writing errors of foreign and Brazilian students and their
perceptions of these errors. This raises questions about linguistic expectations for Brazilian natives
versus foreigners. The central question is: Do teachers have divergent perceptions of deviations in
Portuguese writing in texts by Brazilian and foreign students? Starting from the research question,
we delineate our general objective: to examine how Portuguese native language teachers analyze
texts from foreign and Brazilian students in terms of occurrences of deviations in written
Portuguese. Regarding specific objectives, we seek to understand how teachers perceive the
discrepancies between the writing of a Brazilian and that of a foreigner, as well as how these
perceptions influence their correction approaches, which may vary between more rigorous or more
flexible methods. The hypothesis raised along with the research question was that teachers must
have a differentiated perspective for these two groups of students. We used key concepts from
Saussure (2012 [1916]), Possenti (1996), and Signorini (2006) when discussing different views of
language. We also employed works on "error" and "inadequacies" by Monteiros (2016 [1999]),
Simon (2004), Camara Jr. (1984), Possenti (1996), Zaczek (2012), Hymes (1972), among others.
Finally, we addressed the understanding of the term "stigma," with Goffman (2021 [1988]) as our
reference source. We used a predominantly qualitative approach to explore data in natural contexts,
allowing usto understand the meanings attributed by the participants (DENZIN; LINCOLN, 1994).
Data collection occurred in three phases. In the first, we selected nine texts from Brazilian and
foreign students (coming from languages close and distant from Portuguese). In the second phase,
13 Portuguese teachers evaluated nine texts, each from a different group of students. The third
phase consisted of non-structured interviews with two teachers to triangulate the responses given
in the questionnaire. The results showed differences in the evaluation applied to texts by students
learning Portuguese in various ways, as well as in the teachers' approaches. Throughout the
analysis, we observed that teachers' views on the term "error" were diverse, ranging from
"intralingual errors" to considerations of standard usage. The term "inadequacy" often referred to
linguistic variations, while "deviation" was used to describe grammatical occurrences that did not
hinder text comprehension. Other termssuch as "misunderstanding," "problem," "slip," "incorrect,"
"incoherent," and "difference" were used interchangeably. This diversity of perspectives highlights
the complexity of evaluating student writing.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

