A interface teoria da mente e linguagem: investigando demandas linguísticas na compreensão de crenças falsas de 1ª ordem na aquisição do português brasileiro
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora
DOI
Abstract
This work focuses on the interface between Language and Theory of Mind (ToM),
with emphasis on the reasoning of False Beliefs (FBs). It is investigated whether
linguistic demands interfere with the way in which children in the process of
acquisition of Brazilian Portuguese (BP) deal with standard tasks of First-Order
FBs. The definition of ToM has been understood as the ability of humans to
understand their own mental states and those of others and thus predict their actions
or behaviors (ASTINGTON & GOPNIK, 1988, 1991; FELDMAN, 1992; WELLMAN,
1991). We adopt a psycholinguistic perspective of language acquisition - Syntactic
Bootstrapping (GLEITMAN, 1990), combined with a minimalist conception of
language (CHOMSKY, 1995-2001). We also consider DE VILLIERS’s (2005-2007)
proposal, according to which the syntax of complementation is a prerequisite so that
the domain of ToM can be established. An experimental activity was elaborated and
it consists of three pre-tests and a classic FB task of location-change (cf. WIMMER &
PERNER, 1983). The three pre-tests were applied to 24 children aged 3-4 years old,
in order to verify: (i) the child’s ability to assess the true or false character of certain
propositions from invented stories (ii) the understanding of interrogative sentences
with wh- moved and in situ with epistemic verbs, and (iii) an understanding of simple
and complex sentences with epistemic verbs. Whereas the standard test of FB took
into account the participation of 24 children aged 3-4 years old and also 24 children
aged 5-6 years old. The following linguistic variables were manipulated: a) type of
wh-(in situ and moved), b) sentence type (simple - To John, where is the ball? and
complex - Where does John Think the ball is?). The hypothesis is that the syntax of
complementation is a necessary prerequisite, but not sufficient, so that the domain of
FBs is established. The results indicate that: for the three pre-tests, children in this
age group are able to establish the mapping of an event to a proposition and judge
its truth value, regardless of the syntactic structure in which it appears, in relation
to the task of FB, (i) there was a significant difference between the children’s
responses of both age-groups, because the 3-4 year-old children had a lower
number of correct answers in relation to those of 5-6 years old, (ii) in the responses
involving simple and complex sentences, there was no relevant difference, and (iii)
there was a significant difference in the type of wh- in the 3-4 year-old age group,
because the number of correct answers was higher when there was no displacement
of the interrogative pronoun. These results are consistent with the hypothesis
presented, since the younger children had a very expressive number of correct
answers in both conditions with simple sentences and in those with complex
sentences, and the oldest ones achieved a very significant number in both
conditions. This suggests that the ability to operate recursively and the domain of
epistemic verbs are not sufficient conditions for understanding FBs.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
