Direito fundamental à liberdade em foco: uma análise de conteúdo da decisão do Supremo Tribunal Federal sobre a educação domiciliar
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The academic work in question investigated the treatment given by the Brazilian State,
through the Federal Supreme Court (STF), to homeschooling, a controversial topic that
generates debates both in the academic and political circles. The general objective was to
examine how homeschooling is addressed in the Brazilian legal field. The focus was to
expose the current panorama of homeschooling in Brazil, investigate the philosophical and
legal construction of the right to freedom, and analyze how the STF dealt with the issue in the
case of Extraordinary Appeal (RE) 888.815. The method used was content analysis, which
consisted of a detailed textual analysis of the judgment of RE 888.815, generating quantitative
and qualitative data from the text. The objective was to examine how the fundamental right to
freedom was addressed by the STF, the highest constitutional judicial body in Brazil. The
research hypotheses suggested that, due to the continuity and increase of homeschooling even
after the unfavorable decision of the STF, the fundamental right to freedom addressed by the
court is not compatible with the right to freedom established in the Constitution, which
resulted in the persistence of the practice of homeschooling. In this sense, the results did not
confirm the hypothesis, since the STF did not even analyze the fundamental right to freedom
in its decision, even though the petitioner in RE 888.815 raised this right as a guide for its
legal foundations. Therefore, there were no ways to ascertain whether the fundamental right to
freedom addressed by the STF in the paradigmatic decision was compatible with this right
provided for in the Brazilian Constitution. Thus, it was demonstrated that there is still a latent
need for legal discussion on the subject in view of the insufficient decision-making given to
homeschooling.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

