Uso de ferramentas para aferição do raciocínio clínico no ensino de estudantes de medicina em um cenário hospitalar: estudo randomizado controlado
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Introduction: Clinical reasoning is essential for interactions with patients and
professional colleagues. It involves the synthesis of clinical and investigative data to
generate and prioritize a differential diagnosis and recommend safe and accurate
treatment plans. Clinical reasoning education involves the use of several approaches,
such as the One-Minute Preceptor (OMP) model and SNAPPS (Summarize relevant
patient history and findings; Narrow the differential; Analyze the differential; Probe the
preceptor about uncertainties; Plan the management; Select case-related issues for
self-study). These approaches aim to facilitate students’ learning and optimize their
clinical case presentations. The available research on these approaches is mostly
quasi-experimental and limited to the outpatient setting, and few studies have
compared OMP and SNAPPS. Objectives: To evaluate the effectiveness of OMP and
SNAPPS in teaching clinical reasoning competence to undergraduate medical
students in a hospital setting as compared to a control group (i.e., traditional teaching).
Method: A randomized controlled educational intervention study on the impact of OMP
and SNAPPS educational approaches in developing clinical reasoning competence in
undergraduate medical students at the Federal University of Juiz de Fora (UFJF) was
conducted from July 2018 to December 2019. Students were assessed through preand post-tests in a simulated environment and in the real-world environment, using the
Learning Reflection Scale and the Diagnostic Reasoning Inventory. Results: A total of
256 students were included in the study, with 86 in the control group, 83 in the OMP
group, and 87 in the SNAPPS group. In the pre-test, all three groups were similar in
relation to the variables evaluated. In the post-test, the OMP and SNAPPS groups
performed significantly better than the control group for all outcomes studied in the
simulated environment and the real world. Furthermore, SNAPPS showed superior
results than the OMP groups for discussion time, case presentation quality score,
student performance score, and the number of differential diagnoses presented and
justified. Students and preceptors perceived OMP to be slightly better rated than
SNAPPS, while both scored better than the control. Conclusions: Teaching clinical
reasoning is an important part of medical training, and using approaches that help
structure this process can facilitate student performance. The results indicate that the
use of OMP and SNAPPS approaches is promising for teaching clinical reasoning
competence, especially in a hospital teaching setting for undergraduate students;
therefore, such approaches should be recommended and incorporated into medical
curricula.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

