Presunção de inocência e clamor social: constituição federal e convenção americana no caso da boate kiss
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
This article aims to analyze whether the provisional execution of the sentence in crimes
within the competence of the Jury Court, as provided for in art. 492, I, e, of the Criminal
Procedure Code represents a violation of the guarantee of the presumption of innocence. The
guarantee of the state of innocence establishes the final and unappealable conviction of a
condemnatory criminal sentence as a landmark. The American Convention on Human Rights
also establishes the presumption of innocence as a judicial guarantee of the accused against
the punitive power of the State, not admitting the beginning of the execution of the sentence
before the final judgment. However, Brazilian Law no 13.964/2019 gave new wording to art.
492, I, e, of the Brazilian CPP, to admit that in crimes prosecuted by the Jury, whose sentence
applied exceeds 15 (fifteen) years, the execution of the sentence is immediately initiated. In
order to analyze the performance of the Judiciary in the interpretation and application of these
provisions, the case arising from the fire at the Kiss Nightclub, in which the defendants were
sentenced with immediate execution of the sentence, is used as a concrete case of reference.
The presumption of innocence is adopted as a critical parameter as the accused's right of
resistance against the punitive state power, as defended by Fernando Capez, Aury Lopes Jr.
and Eugênio Pacceli. The research uses a bibliographical analysis of doctrinal, documentary,
legal-positive and jurisprudential sources, especially the decisions handed down by the
Inter-American Court of Human Rights and by the Federal Supreme Court about the
presumption of innocence and the prohibition of the provisional execution of the sentence. It
concludes that the legal provision is unconstitutional, in view of the opposition of the legal
provision to the hierarchically superior norms that make up the Brazilian legal system and the
regional international law, including the application of its logic to the cases of the Jury Court,
as occurred in the the case of Boate Kiss.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

