O fim da obrigatoriedade do recolhimento da contribuição sindical
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This paper aims to analyze the end of mandatory payment of union dues, introduced by
the Labor Reform, with the objective of verifying its compatibility with the Brazilian legal
system, notably with the Federal Constitution of 1988. In order to achieve this, a literature
review was made and the deductive method was used. From a doctrinal review, it was possible
to conclude that the union contribution has a tax legal nature, and this understanding is
peaceful in the jurisprudence of the Brazilian Federal Supreme Court. Furthermore, it was
verified the existence of four doctrinal currents regarding the changes introduced by the
Labor Reform analyzed in the present paper. The first one understands that they are
unconstitutional. The second current understands that, although they cannot be considered
unconstitutional, they are incompatible with the Federal Constitution. The third current
understands that the payment of union dues remains mandatory. The fourth current, adopted
by the Federal Supreme Court in the judgment of ADI nº 5794/DF, understands that the end of
mandatory payment of union dues is legal and constitutional. However, it was concluded that
the changes brought about by the Labor Reform are incompatible with the Federal
Constitution and should be revised, since, as the Constitution adopted the model of mitigated
union freedom, in which the union has the duty to provide the defense of collective and
individual rights and interests of the category as a whole, in judicial or administrative
matters, as well as to participate in negotiations collective work, also for the benefit of all
members of the category, it must also provide those with the financial resources without which
the implementation and maintenance of representation - compulsory and extremely broad -
becomes impossible or, at the very least, impaired and deficient.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

