As reformulações como estratégia argumentativa em audiências preliminares no juizado especial criminal
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This thesis aims to investigate the reformulations of the speech of a conciliator in preliminary
hearings of the special criminal court (JECRIM) in the county of Zona da Mata in Minas
Gerais. In this jurisdictional instance, the preliminary hearings occur before the offer of the
complaint and constitute an oportunity to the realization of an agreement between the parties,
avoiding, thereby, a criminal prosecution. As theoretical-methodological foundations, this
work takes into account the Interactional Sociolinguistics (GUMPERZ, 2013[1982], 1988;
GOFFMAN, 2013[1964]; 1974; 2013[1979]), the studies of Interactional Argumentation
(SCHIFFRIN, 1987; VIEIRA, 2003, 2007, BARLETTA, 2014) and Evaluation (LABOV,
1972; LINDE, 1997; MARTIN e WHITE, 2005). We also recourse to the theoretic constructs
of Ethnomethodological Conversation Analysis (SACKS, SCHEGLOFF e SCHEFFERSON,
1974), as well as the contributions of Maynard (1984), regarding the institutional mandate in
institutional contexts (DREW e HERITAGE, 1992; DEL CORONA, 2009). Our investigative
approach focused, specifically, on reformulations. (GARFINKEL e SACKS, 2012[1970];
HERITAGE e WATSON (1979); BILMES (2011)). This research is from qualitative and
interpretive nature (DENZIN e LINCOLN, 2006), and data were transcribed according to
Jefferson's Model ((LODER e JUNG, 2008). The results show that the conciliator, throughout
the hearings, persecutes the fulfillment of her institutional aim, sometimes dissuading the
parties to seek judicial protection or inducing them to not proceed with the process. To reach
this attempt, she makes several reformulations of positions and its supports. In these
interactional reformulating practices, the conciliator preserves the main meaning of her first
reformulation, that conveys, even if implicitly, her institutional goal, promoting the erasure of
some parts of the utterance to transform them into a gradation of discouragement. Using this
argumentative strategy, the conciliator controls the meeting and reinforce your opinion about
the non-continuity of the process, either by the filing or by the waiver of filing a new
complaint, as well as she retakes bases that support her positions. Thereby, the reformulations
on the speech of the conciliator contribute, argumentatively, to the fulfillment of her
institutional mandate in JECRIM's preliminary hearings.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

