A personalidade como critério para o diagnóstico diferencial entre experiências anômalas e transtornos mentais
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora
DOI
Abstract
Introduction: There is a high prevalence of psychotic experiences in the general
population. Many of these experiences have similar phenomenology to
religious/spiritual experiences (R/E), also called anomalous experiences (AEs), which
are not necessarily pathological. Thus, it is important to find criteria that will guide
mental health professionals to perform a differential diagnosis between an AE and a
mental disorder (MD). A profile analysis of the personality of a person can help to
distinguish whether his/her experiences are healthy or pathological. However, few
studies have been developed to investigate the relationships between AEs and
personality. Spiritist Centers are prime locations to investigate the issue because they
foster AEs and people with AEs often seek help in them.
Objectives: To verify whether personality traits, as measured by the Temperament and
Character Inventory (ITC), can be a criterion for the differential diagnosis between AEs
and MDs. To observe if the dimension of Unusual Experiences (Schizotypy) is
associated with MDs or quality of life (QoL). To observe how different forms of
religiosity are associated with TMs and QoL.
Methods: this is a propective observational cohort study (1 year follow-up) with 115
subjects who had AEs and sought Spiritist Centers in the city of Juiz de Fora/MG.
Instruments: Sociodemographic Interview; TCI-R (Temperament and Character
Inventory, revised and short); Durel - P (Duke Religious Index - in Portuguese);
WHOQOL - BREF (Instrument of Quality of Life of the World Health Organization -
abbreviated); SCID (Structured Clinical Interview for Axis I disorders of the DSM-IV)
O - LIFE - R (Oxford-Liverpool Inventory of Feelings and Experiences- short). Logistic
and linear regression models, controlling for sociodemographic factors, were used to
investigate the associations between personality, dimensions of schizotypy and
religiosity (predictors) with TMs and QoL (outcomes).
Results: The sample was composed of 70% women, mean age 38,8 years (SD 12,5)
55% with higher education level, profile similar to other studies with spirit mediums in
Brazil. There was a current prevalence of 73% of Anxiety Disorders in the sample;
27.8% of Depressive Disorder, 10.4% of Bipolar Disorder and 7% of Psychotic
Disorder. Unusual experiences were not associated with QOL or with MDs. Introverted
Anhedonia was associated with Psychotic Disorder; Impulsive Non-Conformity was
associated with Bipolar Disorder; Novelty Seeking and Reward Dependence were
associated with Bipolar Disorder; Self-Directedness and Self-transcendence were not
associated with the presence of any MDs. No dimension of religiosity was associated
with MD; Cognitive Disorganization was associated with worse QoL in Psychological
domain at T0 and T1; Introverted Anhedonia was associated with worse QoL in all
domains (physical, psychological, social and environmental) at T0 and with worse QoL
in physical domais at T1. Impulsive Non-Conformity was associated with worse QoL in
psychological domain. Self-directedness was associated with better quality of life in
social and psychological domains, at T0 and T1. Harm avoidance was associated with
worse QoL in physical domain.
Conclusions: The results of this study suggest that the analysis of personality traits
(temperament and character) of an individual who presents AEs can serve as an
important criterion for the differential diagnosis between a not pathological experience
and a mental disorder. Future research could investigate about more appropriate
terminologies and theories to explain these nonpathological AEs and we must be careful
not to confuse them with symptoms of MDs.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
