Influência das técnicas de preparo sobre a saúde periodontal de dentes restaurados com laminados cerâmicos: estudo clínico controlado randomizado duplo cego
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This randomized, prospective, double-blind, split-mouth controlled clinical trial
evaluated the periodontal health of permanent upper anterior teeth restored with ceramic
laminates (Experimental group), using a traditional technique with well-defined cervical tooth
preparation and chamfered finish (Control group) and a conservative technique without prior
preparation and finished with a knife blade (CG). From ten participants selected, the sample
consisted of sixty teeth (20 canines [C], 20 lateral incisors [LI] and 20 central incisors [CI])
with clinical indications for CL restorations. For all teeth, lithium disilicate crystal-reinforced
(LiDiSi) e-max CAD glass-ceramic with subgingival margin was used. After cementation,
periodontal parameters were evaluated at baseline (T0), one month (T1), three months (T2) and
six months (T3) and one year (T4), with probing depth (PD, mm) as the primary outcome and
plaque deposition index (PDI), sulcular bleeding index (SBI) and USPHS clinical criteria,
marginal integrity (MI), marginal discoloration (MD), fracture or loss of retention (FLR) and
postoperative sensitivity (POS) as secondary outcomes. Data were analyzed using two-way
ANOVA and Tukey, Student's t or Mann-Whitney, Chi-Square or Fisher's Exact tests and
Kaplan-Meier survival tests, considering a significance level of α 5%. The EG demonstrated
significantly higher probing depth (mm) than the CG from T2 onwards (p 0.001). Regarding
the type of tooth, when compared to the CG, the EG presented greater variation for CI and LI
(p 0.001) and C (p 0.004). While the CG demonstrated 76.7% with plaque deposition index
0, the EG had only 13.3% of these cases. Regarding sulcular bleeding index 1, the CG presented
a reduction of 13.3%, while the EG had a considerable increase, with 93.3% of this index, and
80.0% of the CG obtained sulcular bleeding index 0 and the EG with only 6.7% of the same
clinical condition. In the EG, the plaque deposition index appeared with more cases of
worsening (70.0%) than the CG (23.3%), which had more unchanged cases (66.7%; p 0.001);
In the CG, the sulcular bleeding index showed 53.3% of cases without change and 30.0% of
improvement than the EG (20.0%), which had 80.0% of cases of worsening of this index (p
0.001).Marginal integrity I was present in all cases of the CG and the EG demonstrated 60.0%
with some defect (p 0.001); marginal discoloration was completely absent in the CG, while
83.3% was present in the EG (p 0.007). The CG was completely absent of postoperative
sensitivity, while the EG showed the presence of 23.3% of this criterion (p 0.011). The EG
exhibited 40.0% for marginal integrity, 16.7% for marginal discoloration and 23.2% for
postoperative sensitivity classified as “Bravo” and 10.0% for marginal integrity as “Charlie”.
With a significant difference, the CG presented a success rate of 98.3% for marginal integrity
(p 0.001) and 99.2% for postoperative sensitivity (p 0.003) in relation to the EG for the
same criteria (88.0 and 91.5%, respectively). Thus, it is concluded that, for the preservation of
the periodontal health of permanent upper anterior teeth restored with CL LiDiSi e-max CAD,
this study validates the traditional technique, with subgingival margin and well-defined cervical
preparation with chamfered end for this group of teeth.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Embargado

