Máxima da proporcionalidade e a fundamentação das decisões judiciais: um estudo empírico comparado entre o Supremo Tribunal Federal e o Tribunal Constitucional Federal alemão
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The present investigation aimed to analyze whether the Constitutional Courts of Brazil
and Germany have applied the principle of proportionality in the reasoning of their
decisions in accordance with the theory developed by Robert Alexy (2008). To this
end, bibliographical research was initially conducted, from which the central concepts
related to Alexy’s theory of principles and the principle of proportionality, developed by
him as a method for resolving collisions between principles, were deductively
extracted. Subsequently, an empirical investigation was carried out, based on the case
law of the Supremo Tribunal Federal and the Federal Constitutional Court of Germany.
This stage consisted of an exploratory analysis of decisions delivered between 1973
and 2023, with the aim of identifying how the principle of proportionality has been
addressed by both courts. Through the analysis of a total of 162 decisions, it was
concluded that the rulings issued by both Constitutional Courts present divergences in
the application of the principle of proportionality, developed by Alexy (2008), to
concrete cases. Nevertheless, it was observed that the application of the principle of
proportionality by the Supreme Federal Court reveals a greater departure from the
alexyan model when compared to the decision-making practice of the German Federal
Constitutional Court.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

