O imposto seletivo como instrumento extrafiscal de mitigação das externalidades da indústria fumageira
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The present dissertation is situated within the concentration area “Law and Innovation”,
in the research line “Human Rights, Person and Development: Innovation and Legal
Regulation in the Context of Globalized Capitalism”, of the Graduate Program in Law
and Innovation at the Federal University of Juiz de Fora, by articulating taxation,
fundamental rights, and the legal regulation of harmful economic activities in a scenario
marked by high social, health, and distributive costs. This dissertation aimed to
examine the effectiveness of the extrafiscal function of the Selective Tax, introduced
by Constitutional Amendment no 132/2023 and regulated by Supplementary Law no
214/2025 and Supplementary Law no 227/2026, as an instrument to reduce social
negatives results by discourage the commercialization of products from the tobacco
industry, in light of the protection of collective health, tax justice, and the internalization
of negative externalities associated with smoking. The theoretical framework was
grounded in post-positivist legal theory, particularly the Theory of Law as Social
Practice, in dialogue with neoconstitutionalism and with the centrality of fundamental
rights and tax justice, understanding extrafiscality as a legitimate function of the tax
system aimed at inducing socially desirable behaviors and correcting structural market
imbalances. The research adopted an exploratory design, with qualitative and
quantitative approaches, employing the legal-deductive method, normative analysis of
Constitutional Amendment no 132/2023 and Supplementary Law no 214/2025, as well
the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Brazil from 1988, as an interdisciplinary
literature review in economics and health. In addition, an empirical investigation was
conducted at the Muriaé Cancer Hospital, based on jurimetric analysis of medical
records and the collection of epidemiological and financial data related to lung cancer
between 2015 and 2023. In this context, the analysis of the sensitivity of consumption
to price changes, under scenarios of demand inelasticity, was used as a criterion to
examine the limits of the extrafiscal effectiveness of the Selective Tax, with particular
emphasis on tobacco products. The results of the search has demonstrated that a
mere increase in the tax burden, in a context of inelastic demand, proved insufficient
to significantly reduce consumption and may contribute to exacerbating regressive
effects, disproportionately burdening socially vulnerable groups, in addition to
stimulating dynamics typical of the tobacco sector, such as the expansion of illicit trade
and the intensification of counterfeiting practices. It was also found that, when
implemented in a fragmented manner and reduced to a purely revenue-oriented logic,
the Selective Tax loses its extrafiscal effectiveness and compromises its constitutional
objectives. The study concluded that optimizing the Selective Tax as a behaviorinducing instrument depends on its articulation with integrated public policies, technical
criteria of harmfulness, control and periodic review mechanisms, as well as on the
adequacy of a legal nature to a model that allows the earmarking of revenues by
Institutional framework for preventive, therapeutic, and educational actions, in order to
avoid distributive distortions and ensure compatibility with tax justice and the protection
of fundamental guarantees. Based on these findings, the study presents proposals
aimed at improving the Selective Tax. Among them are the establishment of technical
criteria for the selection of taxable goods and for the calibration of tax rates, combined
with mechanisms for periodic review; the rationalization of the moment of tax incidence
in order to promote greater organization and efficiency in oversight; the readjustment
of its legal nature to allow the creation of institutional mechanisms for the earmarking
of collected revenues; and the establishment of an anti-tobacco fund aimed at
financing preventive, therapeutic, and educational public policies within the Public
Health System, with provisions for transparency, social oversight, and institutional
supervision by oversight bodies and competent courts of accounts.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

