Investigação defensiva e a necessidade de sua implementação no ordenamento jurídico brasileiro
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This work discusses the importance of the defense in the pre-procedural phase
highlighting the police investigation, which is the most used mean of criminal investigation
in Brazil. From the analysis of the procedural operation, it has been demonstrated that the
defense's margin of actuation is negligible within the investigations. This feature generates a
great weapons disparity between accusation and defense, demonstrating the importance of
the defense to be able to carry out the investigation on itself. Thus, it would be possible to
ensure the respect of individual rights and the defense could be to influence the opinio delicti
of the District Attorneyand the groundings of the judge's decision accept or not the D.A.’s
complaint.It was also possible to conclude that the evidence obtained by the criminal
investigation has a great relevance for the procedural phase, because they are not completely
disconnected from the whole process, being required to apply the contradictory principle. An
analysis of the Brazilian Constitution and Foreign Lawswas performed with the objective of
showing that the principles of the lawsuit, ample defense and contradictory principles must
be respected even in the pre-procedural stage. The passive subject must have his right
respected from the beginning of the investigation up until the end of the judicial prosecution
and the Democratic Rule of Law must always protect individual rights. Lastly, it was
performed a study on new rules, laws and draft laws that predict the right for the defensive
investigation. It can be concluded that the broad defense and the contradictory principles are
not fully respected today, mainly due to the absence of the defense in this phase,
demonstrating the importance of its actuation and presence as a guardian of justice system
and its principles.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

