A violação da ordem pública e da soberania nacional como limites à homologação da sentença do caso BHP​

Loading...
Thumbnail Image

Journal Title

Journal ISSN

Volume Title

Publisher

Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares

DOI

Abstract

​This​ ​study​ ​analyzes​ ​to​ ​what​ ​extent​ ​violations​ ​of​ ​public​ ​policy​ ​and​ ​national​ ​sovereignty​ ​operate​​as​​substantive​​limits​​on​​the​​recognition,​​by​​the​​Brazilian​​Superior​​Court​​of​​Justice,​​of​ ​a​​possible​​foreign​​judgment​​related​​to​​the​​BHP​​case​​arising​​from​​the​​Fundão​​dam​​collapse​​in​ ​Mariana.​​The​​research​​addresses​​the​​problem​​of​​how​​Brazilian​​law,​​especially​​article​​24​​of​​the​ ​Code​​of​​Civil​​Procedure​​and​​the​​regime​​on​​foreign​​judgments,​​deals​​with​​parallel​​proceedings​ ​in​​Brazil​​and​​abroad,​​with​​a​​risk​​of​​conflicting​​decisions​​and​​double​​punishment.​​A​​qualitative​ ​bibliographical​ ​and​ ​documentary​ ​approach​ ​is​ ​adopted,​ ​examining​ ​legislation,​​case​​law​​from​ ​the​​STJ​​and​​STF,​​institutional​​documents​​on​​the​​Mariana​​reparation​​scheme​​and​​comparative​ ​studies​​on​​transnational​​environmental​​litigation.​​The​​study​​shows​​that​​recognition​​tends​​to​​be​ ​compatible​​only​​when​​the​​foreign​​decision​​respects​​the​​domestic​​reparation​​framework,​​does​ ​not​ ​produce​​bis​​in​​idem​​and​​does​​not​​replace​​Brazil’s​​structural​​policy​​choices​​regarding​​the​ ​disaster.​​It​​also​​indicates​​that​​invoking​​public​​policy​​and​​sovereignty​​requires​​strict​​reasoning,​ ​in​ ​order​ ​to​ ​avoid​ ​rhetorical​ ​use​ ​that​ ​undermines​ ​international​ ​cooperation​ ​while​ ​preventing​ ​foreign​ ​decisions​ ​from​​disrupting​​the​​socio-environmental​​responsibility​​architecture​​built​​in​ ​Brazil.​

Description

Citation

Endorsement

Review

Supplemented By

Referenced By

Creative Commons license

Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto