A argumentação sobre a prova em vídeo em um processo criminal militar: um estudo de caso
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This paper aims to verify if the recommendation of Kahan (2009), Sherwin (2011) and Silbey (2008) to the visual literacy of law professionals for the interpretation and assessment of video evidence is pertinent to the Brazilian case. Hence, were analyzed the arguments of the Public Prosecutor, the Public Defender, the Military Judge and the Military Minister rapporteur for the appeal in a military criminal case that was processed in Juiz de Fora/MG’s court. This analysis was based on studies by Silbey (2004) and theoretical reference of Textual Linguistics, especially Koch (1986, 2011, 2015) and Thompson and Hunston (2000). Initially, the literature review on the subject was carried out. Afterwards, through the method of the unitary case study and with support in the qualitative analysis of data, were investigated the argumentative linguistic resources and the direction of the argumentative strength employed. Thus, it was verified the treatment of video evidence regarding admission and valuation, influenced by the nature with which it was considered (demonstrative or substantive), the incidence of the silent witness theory in the interpretive activity and the suitability of these procedural actors in dealing with this evidence in audiovisual format. In the end, after the verification of the recommendation of Kahan, Sherwin and Silbey at the country level, it was suggested to carry out new studies to assist in the audiovisual record interpretation activity. These studies could encompass the analysis of the argumentative structure present in the participants' speech, the investigation of the linguistic-discursive marks in these lines and the multimodal transcription of the video test according to the conventions of the Ethnomethodological Conversation Analysis.
Description
Keywords
Prova em vídeo , Alfabetização visual , Recursos linguístico-argumentativos e força da argumentação , Natureza demonstrativa e substantiva , Teoria da testemunha silenciosa , Video evidence , Visual literacy , Linguistic-argumentative resources and strength of argumentation , Demonstrative and substantive nature , Silent witness theory
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
