Compressão pneumática intermitente como estratégia placebo: análise da magnitude do efeito e responsividade da intervenção
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
Ischemic preconditioning (IPC), when applied in the sports context, has gained
significant attention as an emerging ergogenic aid in recent years. Its appeal lies in its
non-invasive, simple, and practical nature, allowing for application both before and
after exercise. However, despite nearly 25 years of research on its ergogenic effects,
a consensus regarding its effectiveness in enhancing performance remains elusive.
Some argue that the heterogeneity of results may stem from a potential placebo effect
associated with its use, although this possibility has not been adequately explored in
the existing literature. Given its inherent presence in the sports context, the analysis of
new potential ergogenic aids should take into careful consideration the placebo effect.
Therefore, the main aim of this thesis was to investigate the potential placebo effect
associated with IPC intervention. Additionally, it aimed to provide an up-to-date
perspective on the real effect of IPC on sports performance. To achieve these
objectives, the thesis comprised three studies. The first study aimed to investigate the
efficacy of IPC intervention in improving performance and discern whether it is primarily
influenced by a placebo effect. The study focused on evaluating the effects of the
simultaneous application of IPC and placebo conditions on resistance exercise (RE)
performance, taking into account the potential influence of subjects' modified
expectations and tactile perception of the cuff. Nine healthy male participants,
experienced in RE, were included in the study. The results did not indicate any
superiority of the IPC intervention in enhancing performance, suggesting the
involvement of a central placebo component. For the second study, the aim was to
broaden the perspective on the placebo response associated with the intermittent
pneumatic occlusion maneuver. This was achieved by manipulating subjects'
expectations in different contexts: positive or negative, while administering a sham IPC
intervention. The study included thirty-five healthy men with experience in RE. The
results revealed a significant influence of the generated expectations on the maximum
number of repetitions. Specifically, the positive manipulation led to an increase in
repetitions, while the negative manipulation resulted in a reduction. These findings
provide compelling evidence of the substantial psychological contribution underlying
the effectiveness of the intermittent pneumatic occlusion maneuver. The purpose of
the third study was to provide an updated state-of-the-art analysis of the IPC
intervention in exercise capacity and athletic performance. In this systematic review
with meta-analysis, sixty-eight studies were analyzed quantitatively. The study
examined three main comparisons: IPC versus Placebo, IPC versus Control, and
Placebo versus Control. The analysis revealed that the IPC intervention did not
demonstrate superior performance improvements compared to the placebo condition
for most of the assessed outcomes. Conversely, the findings revealed that the placebo
condition exhibited a considered impact on performance compared to the control
condition, highlighting its potential effect on the outcomes. In conclusion, based on the
multifactorial nature of the findings and the lack of superiority associated with the IPC
intervention, its use as an ergogenic strategy remains questionable.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

