Com a palavra, o líder: como as lideranças partidárias interferem no processo legislativo no Brasil
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This thesis investigates the role of the coalition's party leaders in coordinating the decisionmaking process in the Brazilian Chamber of Deputies. According to the party explanation,
the president’s constitutional prerogatives, combined with the decision-making
centralization carried out by the leaders, are responsible for high levels of party discipline in
the Legislature and for the Executive’s dominance and success in lawmaking observed in
the post-redemocratization period. This explanation became highly influential in Brazilian
Political Science and opened space for the diversification of research in the area, especially
about the first part of the argument, concerning presidential powers. However, despite the
importance attributed to party leaders, few studies have empirically and deeply examined
the work performed by these actors in legislative coordination. We know that leaders
dominate resources that are expensive to parliamentary activity, such as speaking spaces,
control nominations for important legislative positions and have influence in the so-called
Colégio de Líderes (College of Leaders), but there is little evidence about the processes and
causal mechanisms that connect the actions of leaders with their respective benches and
government to the results of the decision-making process. Considering this gap, this research
aims to examine how party leaders coordinate their caucuses and which factors affect their
activity and the outcomes produced. We start from the hypothesis that leaders resort to
different strategic resources depending on the context, particularly the level of political
conflict and the salience of the issue in the Legislature and public opinion. We believe that
a “descent” to the level of cases is essential to observe the behavior of leaders and what is at
stake in the context of decision-making in each decision-making process. To analyze the
cases of interest, we used the case study methodology associated with Process-Tracing to
select and analyze in a deep four decision-making processes with different conflict levels
around Provisional Measures issued during governments of Lula (2003-2010) and Dilma
(2011-2016). The research showed that party leaders, in addition to using formal procedural
powers, rely on a variety of informal strategies that are decisive in legislative processes. It
also revealed a sort of division of labor between leaders and vice-leaders, suggesting an
internal rationalization of the leadership structure. The analysis further demonstrates that
neither the leaders' procedural powers, nor patronage, nor control of a legislative majority
are sufficient to avoid defeats on key issues for the government. Finally, the research
reinforced the need to rethink the traditional criteria for measuring executive success and
failure in the decision-making process, given its complex and multifaceted nature.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

