A relação entre poder civil e eclesiástico na Carta sobre a tolerância de John Locke: aporia do limite
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
The transition from the Middle Ages to the Modern Age was marked by significant
changes in how the Western world understood the State and religion. In 17th-century
England, this issue first appeared to the philosopher John Locke as a theoretical
question during his time as a student at Oxford, and later as a practical political
problem when he became an advisor to Lord Shaftesbury. Their involvement in
political causes led them into exile in the Netherlands, where Locke met the
Protestant liberal theologian Philip von Limborch, who later published Locke’s famous
Letter Concerning Toleration. In this work, Locke presents his mature view on the
issue, defending a complete separation and independence between the State and
the Church. Although both are grounded in human rationality, they serve different
purposes: the State manages civil and earthly matters, while the Church is
concerned with public worship and the salvation of souls. Lockean tolerance is
therefore built on recognizing the origins and limits of each authority as a condition
for peaceful civil coexistence. However, tolerance must have limits; otherwise, it risks
becoming either antinomianism under the guise of religion or indifference. At this
point, an aporia emerges in Locke’s theory: by granting civil authorities the power to
judge religious sects and imposing active tolerance as a duty on religious groups,
Locke undermines the very separation he defends, subordinating religion to civil
power. Through a systematic exegesis of the First Letter and a historical-contextual
analysis, this study argues that Locke’s claim to rational neutrality ultimately results in
ontological exclusion, encroaching upon the sacred domain it seeks to protect. The
monograph is structured in three parts: historical and biographical context,
systematic exposition of Locke’s arguments, and a philosophical critique of their
internal inconsistencies, contributing to the Brazilian debate on a pluralistic secular
State.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

