Direitos fundamentais à saúde e à educação no Brasil e em Portugal – uma análise comparativa de sua jurisprudência constitucional
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This dissertation investigates how the constitutional courts of Brazil (Supreme Federal Court –
STF) and Portugal (Portuguese Constitutional Court – TCP) ground their decisions regarding
fundamental social rights to health and education, particularly in conflicts involving legal
principles, budgetary constraints, and public policies. The research addresses the issue of
judicialization of these rights in democratic contexts, where the judiciary assumes a central role
in enforcing state obligations, thereby straining administrative discretion, separation of powers,
and constitutional guarantees. The rationale lies in the need to understand the argumentative
patterns guiding jurisprudence in civil law systems with distinct socioeconomic realities. While
Brazil faces structural challenges, such as high demand for medications and treatments under
its Unified Health System (SUS), Portugal debates the sustainability of fundamental social
rights within an established system. The theoretical framework draws on Robert Alexy’s theory
of fundamental rights and legal argumentation. The overarching objective is to identify
convergences and divergences in the reasoning of the STF and TCP, analyzing criteria such as
the principle of proportionality, non-retrogression, the right to a minimum existential level, and
the principle of the reserve of the possible. The methodology combines bibliographic research
with empirical analysis, using constitutional jurisprudence from Brazil and Portugal as
documentary sources. A total of 82 rulings from Brazil and 15 from Portugal, selected between
2000 and 2020 in five-year intervals, were analyzed, with arguments, principles, and sanctions
categorized via standardized documentation. The analysis reveals that the STF prioritizes
normative provisions and precedents, with limited use of legal doctrine, reflecting a pragmatic
approach. Principled balancing is frequent, favoring the right to life and human dignity over
budgetary limitations. In contrast, the TCP integrates more legal doctrine and balances
predominant and overlooked principles, indicating greater inter-branch dialogue. Conclusions
highlight that while the STF treats judicialization as a response to fragile public policies, the
TCP emphasizes cohesion among state powers and budgetary sustainability. Both courts
employ proportionality and rational discourse but diverge in focus: Brazil prioritizes factual
urgencies, whereas Portugal stresses procedural rationality.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

