Simave: percepções e práticas sobre as avaliações sistêmicas da aprendizagem e o Proeb em uma escola da estadual do Vale do Aço (MG)
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
This dissertation was developed as part of the Professional Master's Program in Management
and Evaluation of Education (PPGP) at the Center for Public Policies and Evaluation of
Education at the Federal University of Juiz de Fora (CAEd/UFJF). The research sought to
understand how the appropriation and use of results from Simave – Systemic Learning
Assessments and Public Basic Education System Evaluation Program (Proeb) – are conducted
in a public school in Minas Gerais and how the management of these data influences
pedagogical practices to support the promotion of educational quality. For this purpose, the
objectives defined for this study were to describe and analyze the results provided by the
external assessments that make up the annual Simave calendar (Proeb and Systemic Learning
Assessments), in conjunction with the description and analysis of the practices related to
pedagogical planning based on these data; investigate and analyze the perceptions and
knowledge of the principal, vice principal, specialists in basic education, and teachers regarding
different assessment practices and the use of data provided by Simave evaluations; and propose
actions that contribute to improving the processes of appropriation and use of Simave
assessment results at EECS, based on the analysis of the collected data. It was assumed that the
appropriation of these data is carried out superficially, partially limiting the potential of these
tools. The research employed a qualitative and quantitative approach. To describe the
management case, a bibliographic review of official documents, meeting minutes, and Simave
data was conducted, while field research involved collecting data through semi-structured
interviews with principal, vice principal, specialists in basic education, and a sample of
teachers, as well as questionnaires exclusively for teachers. The questionnaires were analyzed
quantitatively using the Likert scale and supported the development of qualitative analyses. The
theoretical framework included concepts of evaluative practices (Haydt, 2000; Luckesi, 2013;
Luckesi, 2021), discussions on the limitations and possibilities offered to educators by external
evaluations (Lück, 2009; Machado, 2012; Machado; Alavarse, 2014; Fontanive, 2013; Bauer;
Alavarse; Oliveira, 2015; Cunha; Barbosa; Fernandes, 2015; Sahium; Magalhães; Araújo,
2020), and considerations on school performance and educational quality (Demo, 1990; Freitas,
2005; Dourado; Oliveira; Santos, 2007; Dourado; Oliveira, 2009; Gadotti, 2010; Cury, 2014).
The field research revealed that the investigated actors, in part, lack a solid understanding of
the educational evaluation process and tend to engage in individualistic appropriation and
planning. Additionally, issues such as internal communication failures, an excessive number of
tests, and the demotivation of students and teachers, who tend to undervalue the impact of their
actions, were identified. Consequently, an Educational Action Plan was proposed, based on
managerial actions aimed at fostering a culture of collaborative work and promoting the
integration of internal and external assessments.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

