Inversão do ônus da prova: aspectos gerais e entendimentos do STJ sobre o custeio da prova pericial.
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The present work has as objective the analysis of the interpretation from the
High Court of Justice (STJ) before the shift of the burden of proof. For such, were not
only used the doctrinal basis launched in different moments, but also analysis of the
current ordination and the case law applied to the subject. Thus, it was built the
problematization of aspects involving the practice of inversion of evidential burden in
Brazilian law, such as distribution of peritial costs when the institute operates. In
order to have enough theoretical basement to interpret the subject, it was initially
approached the concepts that surround it, as well as the importance of the proof in
the application of the law. Besides all that, the concept of burden of proof was
analyzed, its evolution through the years and its distribution hypotheses, which
involve the knowledge of the established proposition by the Civil Procedure Code
from 2015, Consumer Protection Code, all the developments of judicial activism, the
hypothesis of dynamic distribution of the onus and, finally, the inversion of the burden
of proof. Once all the aspects were analyzed and prior consolidated knowledge over
the subject, it was able to problematize the application of the institute after the
changes of the CPC/2015 and the consolidated understanding by STJ. This way, with
the approach of different doctrinal conceptions, it was understood that the new Code
cemented important legal practices related to the topic. However, the consolidated
knowledge by STJ in the cost of peritial evidence in the hypothesis of the institute
allows solid criticism, based in the appearance of the indirect inversion of financial
burden.
Description
Keywords
Inversão do ônus da prova , Código de Processo Civil de 2015 , Código de Defesa do Consumidor , Custeio da prova pericial , Superior Tribunal de Justiça , Inversion of burden of proof , Civil Procedure Code from 2015 , Consumer Protection Code , Cost of peritial evidence , High Court of Justice (STJ)
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

