Posicionamentos e categorizações: mecanismos retóricos para apresentação/sustentação de pontos de vista em situações de conflito
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This study aims to analyze the rhetorical mechanisms used by participants of a conflict
situation in an institutional context to negotiate points of view and to attribute /be exempt
from responsibility for the troublesome event. From the perspective of Interactional
linguistics (COUPER-KULEN & SELTING, 2001), I based the analysis on the Positioning
Theory (LANGENHOVE & HARRÉ, 1999) and on the Membership Categorization Analysis
(SACKS, 1972) and used as corpus conciliation hearings held in PROCON, a consumer
protection agency. I identified, first of all, how the consumer is positioned in the Consumer
Defense Code (CDC) to then analyze if the positions provides by CDC guided the participants
actions and how the positioning and categorization processes contributed to the management
of divergent points of view and the attribution of responsibility. The analisys showed that the
participants were oriented towards the positions provided by the CDC and made their
positionings by projecting self and other images that acted as a rhetorical tool which worked
to legitimize their own points of view and undermine the others’, attributing responsibility to
the other and exempting the responsibility casted upon themselves. The categorization process
also worked as a rhetorical tool for the process of argumentation, because the categorical
choices of the participants were based on what they wanted to communicate to defend their
arguments and to reject the other arguments.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
