O tratamento da prova em vídeo no processo penal e os vieses cognitivos: um alerta sobre os potenciais impactos da visão em túnel na aplicação do standard de prova quanto à autoria
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The accelerated development of technology, the surveillance society and its
consequences in everyday life have been the subject of several academic studies around the
world, in numerous scientific fields. Inserted in this scenario, this research is dedicated to
investigating some developments in the treatment given to the video as judicial evidence of
authorship in the Brazilian criminal justice system, always starting from a guarantor and,
therefore, rationalist understanding of the national criminal procedural structure. Adopting a
correspondent understanding of truth, the study focused on empirical and epistemological
research methods to analyze whether the impacts of the cognitive bias of tunnel vision from a
video evidence have the capacity to influence the adequate application of the evidentiary
standard imposed for conviction in Brazil. The theoretical frameworks necessary for the
development and understanding of empirical research are exposed, including the treatment of
constant surveillance of the social body as a public security tool, as well as the possible
mental traps to which the interpreter of information transmitted via video is subject, which is
done mainly based on the conceptualization of naive realism as treated by Neal Feigenson.
These mental traps are addressed especially in terms of their relationship with the cognitive
bias of tunnel vision based on the studies by Findley and Scott, to analyze their interaction
with the evidentiary standard imposed for conviction in Brazil: proof beyond reasonable
doubt. Having established these theoretical premises, the research sought to meet the
objective of analyzing whether the video has the capacity to compromise or bias the
application of this standard regarding proof of authorship. Using quantitative and qualitative
research and analysis tools, without prejudice to their exploratory characteristics, the research
focused on criminal judgments handed down throughout 2020 by the TJMG that had at least
one video evidence in their evidentiary framework for analyze the phenomenon under study.
In preliminary analyses, it was possible to point out data that confirm previous studies on
video evidence, such as the evidence that a large portion of judges do not directly watch the
video evidence found by Riccio, Silva, Guedes and Mattos, and Fardim's notes and Guedes
that the production and valuation of video evidence occurs indirectly in most cases. Regarding
the central objective of the work, several variables were applied in different filtering stages,
allowing the identification of eight judgments in which the search for criminal authorship
started from a video, this being the only evidence available in the records. It was concluded
that the particular characteristics of video evidence, intrinsically related to the cognitive bias
of tunnel vision, can directly and negatively influence the judge's decision-making process,
notably when applying the standard of evidence regarding criminal authorship. It was also
possible to point out that the adequate observation of the evidentiary standard can represent an
important tool for weakening this bias, confirming the relevance of the topic and the need for
further academic studies in this sense.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

