Judicialização da saúde e racionalização das demandas: uma análise da jurisprudência do Superior Tribunal de Justiça sobre direito sanitário de 2017 a 2020
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
The present research is developed from the following question: "in the context of
judicialization of health, what is the degree of rationality of the decisions of the
Superior Court of Justice (STJ) regarding this right after the edition of Resolution No.
238, of 06/09/2016, by the CNJ"? The justification for this investigation lies in the
importance of the right to health and the search for its protection by the Judiciary,
which is conventionally called judicialization of health, a phenomenon expressed in
different types of claims, as well as in the duty of the Judiciary to rationally justify its
decisions in a Democratic State of Law, since its legitimacy is argumentative.
Adopting as theoretical reference the thought of Robert Alexy - in particular, his
works Theory of Legal Argumentation (2020) and Theory of Fundamental Rights
(2017), the general objective was set to infer the degree of rationality of judicial
decisions regarding the right to health, judged in the period from 2017 to 2020. The
research consisted of two phases: the first, theoretical and bibliographical, aimed to
investigate the essential concepts for the study, such as the definition of fundamental
social rights, the fundamental right to health and its increasing judicialization in the
country, as well as central concepts of the theory of fundamental rights and the
theory of legal argumentation, both by Robert Alexy. The second part consisted of
exploratory-qualitative empirical-jurisprudential research, analyzing the decisions of
the STJ, within the scope of the right to health, according to the chosen clippings.
Based on Aulis Aarnio (1991), Robert Alexy (1998), Neil MacCormick (2008) and
AleksanderPeczenik (2009), rationality was focused on two prisms: logical and
substantial. At the end, it was concluded that although it has been found an
argumentation focused primarily on institutional arguments (with the exception of
doctrine), this reality did not compromise its level of rationality, since the logical
rationality (in 91% of the decisions), as well as the substantial rationality (in 82% of
them) were high.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

