A (in)constitucionalidade da aplicação do in dubio pro societate nas decisões de pronúncia no rito do tribunal do júri
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
This paper aims to critically analyze the application and constitutionality of the
principle in dubio pro societate, applied in the 1st phase of the two-step procedure of
the jury. It will be shown that this aphorism is widely used by Brazilian jurisprudence,
by individual judges and courts (on appeal) as well. Occurs that, after study of the
Constitution and many laws, there isn't any legal support for the use of predicted
principle. Will be observed that in dubio pro societate is a rancid of pre-1988
constitution period, which actually ensured many diametrically opposed aphorisms to
in dubio pro societate, as the wide defense and the contradictory, in dubio pro reo,
due legal process etc. Thus, it will prove that in dubio pro societate, unlike defending
by the majority jurisprudence, deathly injures constitutional rights that are important
to any country that considers itself as a democratic state based on the rule of law,
and, therefore, its application is extremely wrong and harmful. Finally, supporting the
defended in this work, will be highlighted the rise of a jurisprudence (still a minority)
that rejects the use of in dubio pro societate, for also understand that this principle is
not appropriate in current Brazilian democratic state that obeys the rule of law.
Description
Keywords
1ª fase do procedimento do júri , Aplicação do in dubio pro societate , Ausência de respaldo jurídico , Desrespeito a princípios constitucionais , In dubio pro reo , Rechaço por doutrina minoritária , 1st phase of jury procedure , Application of in dubio pro societate , Absence of legal support , Disregard for constitutional principles , In dubio pro reo , Rejection by minority doctrine
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
