O poder geral de efetivação das decisões judiciais: uma análise crítica e constitucional do artigo 139, inciso IV, do código de processo civil
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
The general power of effectiveness of judicial decision, instituted by the article 139,
subsection IV, from the Code of Civil Procedure, enshrines the atypicality of executive
measures, so that the judge, faced with the ineffectiveness of the typical means may
apply inductive, coercive, mandatory or subrogatory measures not typified by law.
Occurs that, the scope of possibilities by virtue of the application of such a norm
implies, in the light of the General Theory of the Constitutional Process, mainly from
the point of view of Luiz Guilherme Marinoni, Sérgio Cruz Arenhart and Daniel
Mitidiero, and the doctrine and theory of Fundamental Rights by Robert Alexy, the
establishment of limits for the jurisdictional action, in order to guarantee the
effectiveness and proportionality of its guardianship. Having said that, from the critical,
constitutional and empirical analysis of art. 139, IV, from the CCP, the magistrate must
observe and consider relevant criteria to its proper application, thus establishing the
unavailable limits of the measures allowed under violation penalty of individual rights
in order to obtain the satisfaction of pecuniary claims, as occurred in the decision of the
case number 4001386-13.2013.8.26.0011 of the TJSP, which ordered the suspension of
the convicted’s National Driver's License, the cancellation of his credit cards and the
seizure of his passport until the discharge of the debit. Such a decision was revoked due
to the impetration of Habeas Corpus. It is emphasized that the ideal is to embark on the
modular logic, that is, the search for suitable solutions to the case in counterpart to
generic solutions, of alleged abstract and universal adequacy, so that the judge's action
before the application of article 139 is compelled by the active participation of the
parties, not only with the adversary, but also with their autonomy for the juridical
proceedings; as well as by the Constitution, law, jurisprudence, the procedural legal
dogma and the Theory of Law, controllable in the broad duty of judicial justification,
establishing the unavailable limits of atypical measures.
Description
Keywords
Poder geral de efetivação , Atipicidade de medidas executivas , Princípios da proporcionalidade , Razoabilidade e patrimonialidade , Direitos fundamentais , General power of effectiveness , Atypicality of executive measures , Proportionality principles , Reasonability and patrimonialty , Fundamental rights
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Rights and licensing
Acesso Aberto
