O principio da reserva do possível e a ponderação: uma proposta de critérios para análise da confiabilidade epistêmica de premissas empíricas e normativas
Loading...
Date
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
Abstract
An increasing number of lawsuits have been proposed in an attempt to guarantee the
enforcement of constitutionally recognized rights and, as a consequence, to prevent the
inaction or deficient performance of the Public Administration. The filing of these actions, as
a rule, aims to achieve compliance with the obligation to do, consisting of material benefits
not spontaneously offered by the Public Power, and consequently, the recognition and
correction of possible state omissions in the implementation of fundamental rights. The
principle of reserving the possible constitutes, along with the principle of separation of
powers, the main argument to justify the impossibility of meeting these benefits and other
state obligations that involve the expenditure of public resources. However, the approach to
the principle has occurred without the adoption of sufficient technical criteria for its correct
application. This situation can result in both the granting of undue benefits, in the absence of
adequate procedural evidence that leads to the uncertainty of the allegations and premises
presented by the Government, as well as the denial of due and reasonable benefits, due to the
common sense appeal that hangs over the presumption of scarcity of public resources for the
provision of services that materialize fundamental rights. It also allows for the proliferation of
contradictory decisions in similar situations, to the detriment of legal certainty and isonomy in
the treatment of the courts. The research is divided into two parts. The first, an exploratory
and deductive bibliographic research on the theoretical aspects of the principle of the reserve
of the possible, passing through its conceptualization, its incorporation in the national legal
system, its relationship with the fundamental rights and budgetary rules, until reaching the
survey of parameters objectives for measuring the epistemic reliability of the empirical and
normative premises, in line with the refined weight formula proposed by Robert Alexy, the
theoretical framework used. The second part contains the empirical research carried out in
order to quantify the occurrence of the parameters listed in the jurisprudence of the Federal
Supreme Court and the Superior Court of Justice, in order to assess the degree of epistemic
reliability in which the decisions of these courts have been handed down.
Description
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

