O papel da perícia sobre a prova em vídeo na era das deepfakes: um estudo de casos
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
In the digital society, the spread of videos and the advance of deepfakes strain the
reliability of video evidence and bring forensic examination to the center of debates on
authenticity and integrity. This study investigates the role of forensic examination over video
evidence by reference to two high-profile cases flagged as possible deepfakes, examining the
qualification of experts, the methods and techniques employed, the use or nonuse of artificial
intelligence for detection, and the structure of forensic conclusions. Guided by the rationalist
conception of evidence, according to which the function of evidence is the knowledge of facts,
the study adopts the premise that only falsifiable and potentially reliable knowledge should
enter the process, so quality standards must be set for the admissibility of a video, especially in
view of the cognitive and interpretive biases of this digital means of proof. The need to state
and apply probative standards for the admissibility and evaluation of video evidence is
sustained, including minimum quality requirements for the material. Deepfakes, as byproducts
of artificial intelligence and constantly improved by machine learning, can be detected through
three avenues, namely through the chain of custody, through tools specifically developed for
that purpose, and through human-based analysis, and the epistemic limitation of each method
is addressed. The case study, which analyzed eight forensic reports, identified that the third
avenue, grounded in the human eye as the predominant tool, was the one used by experts
through frame comparison and comparative observation of elements such as lighting and
synchrony, with software serving only as support and with indirect mentions to the chain of
custody. The case study confirmed the importance of establishing quality standards, since
limitations such as low resolution, sharpness, and lighting, which affect inferential robustness,
were indicated by experts as epistemic limitations. It is concluded that hybrid detection methods
that combine a rigorous chain of custody, tools for detection based on artificial intelligence, and
a scientifically and methodologically guided human comparative examination, together with
literacy and visual literacy as transversal competencies for reading videos, are the best
instruments to prevent deepfakes from compromising the truth pursued as an ideal and
attainable aspiration.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

