Avaliando as plataformas de ciência cidadã para o estudo da migração altitudinal de aves
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora (UFJF)
DOI
Abstract
Altitudinal migration is the seasonal movement of individuals from reproductive to nonreproductive areas, and vice versa, along an altitudinal gradient. Studies on the subject are still
scarce and, as the costs and logistics of field studies are some of the restraints, using citizen
science can be a strategy to ensure advances in understanding this behavior in birds. Thus, we
sought to evaluate the efficiency and feasibility of data from the eBird and WikiAves platforms
to detect the altitudinal migration of birds in Brazil, also investigating the relationships of
behavior with environmental variables. We selected 12 species recognized as migratory by the
literature, in addition to six residents for comparison. We defined the Brazilian East as the
sampling area and, due to differences in the platforms, for the eBird data, we divided the area
into cells and calculated the variables for each one. For WikiAves, we used the municipalities
as the sampling unit. First, we ran two zero-inflated binomial generalized linear mixed models
(GLMMs) from the eBird data, one for migratory species and one for residents, which was not
possible for WikiAves due to the low sample size. Due to the large variance of the species as a
random effect factor, we ran new zero-inflated GLMMs for each species using both platforms.
The models showed differences in the temporal pattern of occurrence between resident and
migratory altitudinal species, confirming the potential of eBird data to infer the species'
altitudinal migration behavior. In the species-level models, the resident species data followed
the expected, while three migratory ones followed the expected pattern of altitudinal
seasonality. In this sense, our models show that the seasonal pattern of occurrence of migrant
species was different from the resident ones, as expected in the case of validity of the eBird
platform data. The specific models, in turn, confirmed the diversity of behaviors, with only
three models of migratory species following the expected one. The diversity of responses, in
itself, is plausible and expected for the altitudinal migratory movement, since it is guided by
diverse variables that interact with each other and may vary between populations of the same
species. In addition to the complexity of the movement, it is also possible that variations
between populations result in additional and uncontrollable sources of noise in the models. Even
so, the results obtained in the general models proved to be reliable given the established
predictions, demonstrating that, in certain circumstances, it is possible to use citizen science
data in the study of altitudinal migration. However, more refined analyses at the species level
may suffer from noise, possibly making the use of these data feasible only in conjunction or
with more refined studies of movement ecology. Thus, we conclude that citizen science data
may allow studies of the altitudinal migration of birds in Brazil in certain situations. It is up to
future ecology movement studies to refine the scenarios so that citizen science data is more
effective.
Description
Keywords
Citation
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

