Uma corte de razões individuais: obstáculos à identificação da ratio decidendi no Supremo Tribunal Federal
Loading...
Date
Authors
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Universidade Federal de Juiz de Fora - Campus Avançado de Governador Valadares
DOI
Abstract
This article analyzes the deliberative process of the Brazilian Supreme Court (BSC), mainly
regarding the form of collegiate decision-making and obstacles to the identification of the
court’s ratio decidendi. Collegiality as a constitutional rule requires that multi-personnel
bodies build their decisions in a way that allows for the exchange of arguments in the search
for consensus, observing the determining foundations of decisions in the future judgments.
Therefore, the application of precedents necessarily depends on the identification of the ratio
decidendi of the Court’s decisions. However, the institutional practice of the BSC seems to be
shaped by the soloist performance of the justices, who build individual reasons between the
judges, who form a final decision as a junction of individual opinions. Articles on Brazilian
constitutional jurisdiction are adopted as a critical parameter, especially regarding the ideal of
deliberation of a constitutional court, as analyzed by Conrado Hübner Mendes. The
qualitative research, with a critical and comprehensive character, makes use of doctrinal,
legal, regulatory and jurisprudential sources, with emphasis on the Internal Regulations of the
BSC and its implications for the decision-making practice of the Court. It is concluded that
the BSC can be considered a non-deliberative Court in view of regulatory aspects, the form of
decision-making, the absence of interaction between the Ministers and the form of the final
wording of the Court.
Description
Citation
Collections
Endorsement
Review
Supplemented By
Referenced By
Creative Commons license
Except where otherwise noted, this item's license is described as Acesso Aberto

